Silva
Arcane
Invictus, I recommend you read Roadside Picnic from the Strugatsky brothers. Its the work that originated the "saga", and its the best one for me, much better than the movie (I dont like it) and better than the games. I was always bugged by the movie in a way I couldnt exactly put my finger on , until Ive read the book again and then things got clear:
- the movie looks like a sunday morning sermon by the local father speaking in full latim. It proselitizes a certain "thing" and wants the spectators to reach for it and almost makes you guilty for not doing so. But its never clear what is it. It almost suggests something in the likes of "if you´re really worthy, you will know what all this mean and will be saved in the end". Its feels religious and manicheistic to me.
- on the other hand, the book dont make judgements. It simply shows the protagonists dillemas in relation to the harsh life in and around the Zone, and the consequences of their choices. Like ripples on a pond. Then it dissects and comments on these outcomes, but it never judges them, nor tries to give some "higher" meaning for one choice over another, etc. It feels much more imparcial to me.
- the movie looks like a sunday morning sermon by the local father speaking in full latim. It proselitizes a certain "thing" and wants the spectators to reach for it and almost makes you guilty for not doing so. But its never clear what is it. It almost suggests something in the likes of "if you´re really worthy, you will know what all this mean and will be saved in the end". Its feels religious and manicheistic to me.
- on the other hand, the book dont make judgements. It simply shows the protagonists dillemas in relation to the harsh life in and around the Zone, and the consequences of their choices. Like ripples on a pond. Then it dissects and comments on these outcomes, but it never judges them, nor tries to give some "higher" meaning for one choice over another, etc. It feels much more imparcial to me.