Lancehead
Liturgist
- Joined
- Dec 6, 2012
- Messages
- 1,550
Because evidently the choice is weighty because whichever you choose, the other town gets wiped out. Resources can well be a consideration in the choice, but there are also lives of dozens of people hanging in the balance, and your decision affects them, which is why having personal interaction can be important. Of course, you might decide that resources are more important than any of the people, but at least then you're making that decision knowing the people. It would make a better choice to make.Why do you necessarily have to visit? A bit of information, even over the radio, could provide 'meaningful considerations' to the choice. Perhaps one town has a number of children and the other has a medical centre. Or one has a useful stash of weapons but the other has vital food and medical supplies. And then the choice would influence the future direction of the game. But even if we knew absolutely about the towns (unlikely I guess) I still prefer options to a railroad.My problem with it is that it seems that you never get to visit and know those places before making the decision, which means there would be no meaningful considerations in picking one place to save over the other. That can make the choice weightless and the consequence devoid of any impact, emotional or otherwise.
Also, where did I advocate "a railroad"?
As for attempting to save both towns, it really depends on how party-splitting is implemented. If it's a general mechanic, as opposed to a scripted event, then I don't see why the player shouldn't be allowed to split the party and try and save both towns. In fact, not allowing so would be a railroad.Must say I don't really get all the butthurt over this choice. Instead of being railroaded into the first few scenes you get alternate paths through the game, adding interest and replayability. But so many comments are along the lines of "why can't I save both" or "I want to visit them both before deciding". It's a desperate struggle for survival, one of these towns will get raped and minced, and no you can't have all the prizes.