Decline Why wasn't there a 2023 RPGCodex GOTY?

[Lord_Potato]

let's do it oldschool, like in the previous years. this way we'll get not only GOTY but also some other interesting findings that someone could otherwise miss.

 

[Saduj]

You have nothing to worry about. Nobody cares what I think. And being right doesn't entitle me to tell the people who spend their own time working on this how to do things.

 

[Infinitron]

I was waiting to see what would come out of that thread about a new Top 100 poll, but I guess it's going to take a while to reach any consensus.

I'm ok with doing the poll this weekend, but I expect a very predictable result... I doubt enough people actually played stuff like Moonring, Hero's Adventure, Lunacid, Quester, Demon Lord Reincarnation, Tales of Immortal, Legends of Amberland II, Wizardry: The Five Ordeals or Caves of Lore. Will be just Jagged Alliance 3, Colony Ship and Rogue Trader fighting for #2 and #3.

The problem is Rogue Trader and Colony Ship which were released in December. I don't want to see a bunch of people complain that the poll is bad because they haven't played them yet. How long do we wait to give end-of-year releases a fair shot?

Owlcat games you either play on release and/or after like 2-3 years of patches and DLCs, I doubt there's anyone who wants to jump in the next few weeks.

Very well then. You should post your list of games before publishing the poll on the front page, so that we don't forget anything.

Also, I guess Twiglard will need to set up the Codex-integrated polling system again.

 

[felipepepe]

Yo, I did the games list and a thread to discuss it: https://rpgcodex.net/forums/threads/goty-2023-games-list-discussion.149592/