I havent even played Outer Worlds and I got it for free.
I did. It felt like a waste of time.
nobody can seriously claim that it had better gameplay than either of Pillars of Eternity games.
Watch me make that claim. I just recently finished BG1, TotSC, SoD, BG2, and ToB.
I recently beat PoE1 and replayed BG1 and it's not even close. Both games feature too many trash fights but at least PoE1 occasionally requires you to change your strategy. I was challenged on occasion on second highest difficulty in some of the early fights (like anytime I had to fight shadows) and even some DLC fights like the final fight of WM1 and even some trash fights there. Meanwhile the only fights I found truly difficult in BG1 was that demon at the end of Soultaker quest chain.
All martial classes in AD&D are auto attack bots with zero thought required to play them. Most wizard spells are pretty underwhelming and you can get by with spamming a few really OP spells. Not to mention how easy it is to break enemy AI in BG1 by just kiting around. There's nothing challenging in that game, sorry.
BG2 drastically improves mage combat but other classes remain equally dull.
Meanwhile, character building in PoE1 and especially PoE2 is incredibly rich and fun. There are countless possible viable builds in Deadfire that all play very different from each other. PoE also has very refreshing new classes (cipher) and new takes on standard fantasy classes (chanter, monk) that help keep it fresh.
Sorry, as much as I love BG1 I just don't see any part of it's gameplay that's better than PoE1 or Deadfire.