hell bovine
Arcane
The problem with all those "patterned" backgrounds is that they kind of... dimnish (for a lack of better word) the effect of the original design.Well fuck it, I just decided to add a 2px accent to the wood background and about 10 px of faint-ish shading to the original main menu background to achieve a wood cut out effect and here's the result. Look at the skull and the bottom border, I think it looks p good and not too jarring/overly creative.Out of what's here, I'd honestly go for passerby's suggestions. The idea of Victorian frames are cool but without an actual artist doing work on it specifically it's currently way too jarring.
In the original, the wooden background makes the menu stand out, because it contrasts with the black surrounding it. When you add a similar wooden effect all around, this contrast isn't as strong and the menu looks lost in all this "woodennes". On the other hand, in the 'fade to black' picture the darkness is just too much.
- Which is why I liked the mage & dwarf version the best. It didn't tinker with the contrast, but did away with the darkness monotony. If you can't find any high-res art, maybe a steampunk-styled photo would work?