I've played a little gothic 3. I can't believe how un customizable their engine is. I mean, all you have is a detail setting and that's basically IT. Controls are horrible, the mouse look feels like it's tuned for grandpa's ancient reflexes. I'm an FPS developer/player so no wonder Oblivion worked for me. I dont' like how clunky Gothic feels. No character either? They decide what your character looks like? Ok so on the plus side, the distant blur effect isn't too bad, and your character has animations for harvesting alchemy stuff and he actually has an eat animation. It's got some things going for it, but it's no Oblivion for sure.
I think it's weird how once you get used to a game, you just want more of it. Like I've played thorugh countless characters with oblivion, and of course use lots of mods. Personally I think Bethesda could charge for updates like wow and make my 10 bucks a month the rest of my life if they wanted to, provided some decent content came down the pipes each month. I mean, I just want more Oblivion, not another game really. It's like I'm addicted to it and I don't even like trying other stuff too much. Maybe I feel like it's just going to be a disappointment. That is how great games are though, like most sequels make people who liked the original angry, even if it's better by most newcomers standards. Just like some of you love morrowind, say it's better than Oblivion, I'm sure i"ll say Oblivion is better than Tes 5. It's whatever you are used to, etc.