Putting the 'role' back in role-playing games since 2002.
Donate to Codex
Good Old Games
  • Welcome to rpgcodex.net, a site dedicated to discussing computer based role-playing games in a free and open fashion. We're less strict than other forums, but please refer to the rules.

    "This message is awaiting moderator approval": All new users must pass through our moderation queue before they will be able to post normally. Until your account has "passed" your posts will only be visible to yourself (and moderators) until they are approved. Give us a week to get around to approving / deleting / ignoring your mundane opinion on crap before hassling us about it. Once you have passed the moderation period (think of it as a test), you will be able to post normally, just like all the other retards.

Bottom 5 Worst RPGs You Ever Played

Falksi

Arcane
Joined
Feb 14, 2017
Messages
11,031
Location
Nottingham
Looks like people rather are coming up with their hate lists than bother recalling various obscure trash. I can recall only a few of them: Konung 2 and Heath: The Unchosen Path (Златогорье) + Goldenland: Cold Heaven (Златогорье 2). Don't see a point to list here even amobinations like Fallout 3, really.

When I posted mine I thought that's how it'd be perceived, but I genuinely had the worst experience with those games.

You could say stuff like Lagoon is objectively worse, but I didn't play that long enough to suffer. The ones on my list I played for far longer than I should because of their hype, and that makes them far worse for me as the rankness lasted longer.
 

Modron

Arcane
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
11,116
I've played many games and not once thought this is worse than NWN OC. I would imagine if I ever got desperate enough to play Oblivion I would still probably say it's better than NWN OC. NWN OC is the shittiest rpg I have played; I would play E.T. the Extraterrestril before I would ever replay the OC again.

Do you just want people to start listing 99 cent asset flip rpgs on steam that nobody bought nor played?
 
Joined
Jan 14, 2018
Messages
50,754
Codex Year of the Donut
I've played many games and not once thought this is worse than NWN OC. I would imagine if I ever got desperate enough to play Oblivion I would still probably say it's better than NWN OC. NWN OC is the shittiest rpg I have played; I would play E.T. the Extraterrestril before I would ever replay the OC again.

Do you just want people to start listing 99 cent asset flip rpgs on steam that nobody bought nor played?
I would imagine people who discuss RPGs actually have played more than 5 of them
 
Joined
Sep 5, 2020
Messages
1,258
Location
Germania
1. Fallout 3: Todd Howard turned Harold into a god damn tree. A TREE.
2. Baldur's Gate 3: I never asked for DOS 3 or more barrelmancy, Swen.
3. Oblivion: Fallout 3 with swords.
4. Skyrim: Voice actors phoned it in: The Game. And incredibly repetitive.
5. Torment: Numa Numa: It is kind of like an adventure game, but without the fun.
 

dumbuglyorc

Educated
Joined
Oct 7, 2021
Messages
80
In no particular order:

The Witcher 1 & 2. I lump them into one, as I despise both for the same reason. Fucking hate an rpg that tries to force me to play a cringe-"cool" whatever-the-hell-that-troll-is. I went into the first one all excited about what I'd heard, but after holding in the vomit for a couple hours I was so done. Sadly, I suspect there may be a nice game hidden beneath that absolutely hideous main character, but I just couldn't... And that's why I made the repeat mistake with 2, but this time I played it probably for less than a minute. I think I uninstalled the moment I heard the first voiced line by the turdnugget. Never again.

And we all know by now that Gerbert, or whatever, likes to touch little kids while rubbing stale eggs onto his throbbing cock. Ptooey.

Oblivion. 'nuff said.

Oblivion: New Vegas. This was admittedly one of the better fps games I've played, but I still prefer playing the shittiest shovelware rpg or strategy game imaginable over any fps.

System Shock II. I think I've seen people call this abomination an rpg? If so... clunky, vapid fps with respawning enemies everywhere? I was in, and I was out. No thanks.

I'm missing one, but can't think of anything equally disappointing at the moment. I may be back.
 

agris

Arcane
Patron
Joined
Apr 16, 2004
Messages
6,927
i lol'd at oblivion: nv. people aren't gonna like that one, there's a lot of love for fallout: gamebryo here
 

wishbonetail

Learned
Joined
Oct 18, 2021
Messages
671
1 Oblivion-butchered Morrowind
2 Fallout3- raped Fallout
3 Mass Erect- lame KotoR
4 Dragon Age - Baldurs Gate for special people
5 Another War- because I played it recently and it has the shitiest of shits 2d isometric combat that I ever experienced.
 

JarlFrank

I like Thief THIS much
Patron
Joined
Jan 4, 2007
Messages
34,371
Location
KA.DINGIR.RA.KI
Steve gets a Kidney but I don't even get a tag.
I've played many games and not once thought this is worse than NWN OC. I would imagine if I ever got desperate enough to play Oblivion I would still probably say it's better than NWN OC. NWN OC is the shittiest rpg I have played; I would play E.T. the Extraterrestril before I would ever replay the OC again.

Do you just want people to start listing 99 cent asset flip rpgs on steam that nobody bought nor played?

Yeah I can vibe with that.

NWN 1 is among the worst RPGs ever, especially when you consider its reputation for being good, which is for some reason holds (probably because of the multiplayer).
 
Joined
Jan 14, 2018
Messages
50,754
Codex Year of the Donut
I've played many games and not once thought this is worse than NWN OC. I would imagine if I ever got desperate enough to play Oblivion I would still probably say it's better than NWN OC. NWN OC is the shittiest rpg I have played; I would play E.T. the Extraterrestril before I would ever replay the OC again.

Do you just want people to start listing 99 cent asset flip rpgs on steam that nobody bought nor played?

Yeah I can vibe with that.

NWN 1 is among the worst RPGs ever, especially when you consider its reputation for being good, which is for some reason holds (probably because of the multiplayer).
Shadows of undretide/hordes of underdark
 

Drowed

Arcane
Joined
Dec 28, 2011
Messages
1,744
Location
Core City
Honestly, I don't think I remember the worst RPGs I played because I probably gave up early on, so they didn't stick in my memory long enough for me to even remember them to make a list. That said, I have some examples of RPGs that I tried to play and like but just couldn't, and I remember them precisely because I tried several times.

1) Oblivion - I lost count of how many times I tried to play this game only to give up in the first few hours. I even tried to download famous/recommended mods and had all the trouble of tuning everything perfectly only to give up soon after and quit the game.
2) Fallout 3 - Same case as above, essentially.
3) NWN1 - This is a special case because I've played several modules over the years, some that I quite enjoyed. But I never managed to finish the original campaign.
4) 7th Saga - I tried several times because it was one of the few SNES RPGs I never finished from the store where I rented the cartridges at the time. Maybe my memory is failing me, but I remember that the grinding was unbearable.
5) Final Fantasy 13 - Goddam, I had forgotten about this game, but now that some have spoken in this thread about it, yeah! I remember trying to play it several times but always abandoning it because I got so bored that I simply forgot the game even existed.
 

KeighnMcDeath

RPG Codex Boomer
Joined
Nov 23, 2016
Messages
15,422
we can't have anything nice because people refuse to even fucking read the second sentence in the OP
Has it occurred to you that not everyone plays bargain bin rpgs and thus has a very different point of reference
Almost ALL games eventually become bargain bin games.

"Since we've had several top 5 and top 10 polls here, how about the opposite - what are your bottom 5 RPGs?

These are truly the bottom of the barrel. I famously despise Neverwinter Nighs, and I hate Oblivion for what it did to the genre... but there are way worse games in existence. Games so bad you want to get the time back you wasted on them."

I had to delete my list. As I replayed games on that list more than thrice. I'll have to really think on what abandonware or ancient ware I played and just couldn't finish or had a horrible time. I mean I hate Hylide but I've replayed that fucker many times and different incarnations. Ultima II is a terrible grind and I enjoy grinding (probably lack of enemies at times). Swords & Serpents has annoying music and combat is just BLEK! (Mostly just push a button). Questron II just didn't seem as good as the original nor as good as LOTA or LOBS. Spelljammer PORS had fucktard boarding combat, inane menus, and god fucking awful music but I loved the idea of space boats and privateering. I wanted the SPELLJAMMER or some uber custom ship. The game left me very sour. I just have a habit of replaying games.

I have Spacesiege and managed to get it to run. It is inferior to DS but I haven't given up on it. I'll eventually get Numen (much to Seinfeld's chagrin).
 
Last edited:

Humbaba

Arcane
Joined
Aug 12, 2021
Messages
2,940
Location
SADAT HQ
Joined
Oct 25, 2012
Messages
232
1) Dungeon Lords - Fuck D.W. Bradley

2) NWN 1 - Utter trash

3) Oblivion - shit which gutted everything that made Morrowind a bit unique / interesting

4) Gorasul - IIRC buggy, poorly translated and crap design

5) Diablo - mostly because it was a harbinger of things to come... But there are plenty more terrible cRPGs - MM9, Dungeon Siege, PoR: RoMD, ect.
 

wishbonetail

Learned
Joined
Oct 18, 2021
Messages
671
we can't have anything nice because people refuse to even fucking read the second sentence in the OP
Has it occurred to you that not everyone plays bargain bin rpgs and thus has a very different point of reference
Almost ALL games eventually become bargain bin games.
So is any kind of sexual intercourse necrophilia because eventually everyone dies??????
Yes. You should ditch that stuff.
 
Self-Ejected

Thac0

Time Mage
Patron
Joined
Apr 30, 2020
Messages
3,292
Location
Arborea
I'm very into cock and ball torture
5) Divinity Original Sin
This is a combined place for both titles, since I can't decide on which annoys me more. Both bait you on with a fundamentally solid first act, then the quality gradually lowers as you keep playing, until you are left wondering why you aren't playing a better game in your free time. Both of the games have boring scaled loot and fucked up combat systems where the floor is glass shards and used syringes infected with herpes, and you can lose your turn for moving half a field, triggering a chain reaction of lightning, blood and water which apparently create mustard gas.
The first game is stunlock central, the second game tries to fix that through the armor system, which somehow makes the combat degenarate even more into stunlock central after 10 hours in.

4) NwN 1 OC
I tried to like this game after spending an decent amount of time in the character creator, but the OC maximises boringness. Also minus points for the battle academy start being MMO opening levels of bad.

3) Shadows of Adam
A bit of a "literally what?" pick. Symbolises all these kickstarter rpgs trying to catch the nostalgia of a better title without understanding what made that title tick in the first place, while trying to solve perceived flaws of that title, which in turn makes the game worse. It is a 16-bit SNES rpg copy with shit writing, characters devoid of charisma, only 3 equipment slots, no interchangable characters, simplicistic skill sets, no leveling system and nothing else that could bring up fun. If someone wants a stereotypical strawman of a JRPG to hate without any of the benefits, look no further than Shadows of Adam.

2) Dragon Age Inquisition
Expectation is everything for a game. For the longest time I harbored a strong dislike against Dragon Age Origins, as it is hyped as a 10/10 GOTAY by retards, while being merely an adequate slightly sub bar rpg overall. Dragon Age II has the reputation of a burning trash fire, so I was not surprised to find a mostly awfull game. Inquisition had the reputation of being a return to form, and arguably the best game of the series among normies, so I was surprised to find the most boring game of the series. MMO tier zones and sidequests have nothing to do in classical crpgs, and make the gameplay a mixture of chore and busywork.

1) Final Fantasy XIII
This game is atrocious for dozens of reasons, but it all culminates in the fact that it is the dumbing down of video games on the PS3, with less and less gameplay and exploration and more and more expensive assets and cutscenes, brought to a peak. Looks good, sounds good, utterly boring.
 
Joined
Mar 3, 2010
Messages
9,268
Location
Italy
grimoire
cyberpunk
dragon age 3 (perhaps only because i skipped 2)
lionheart
oblivion + bethesda fallouts (they're all the same game after all)
so many for the honorable mention, crap like operencia, neverwinter nights, divine divinity (pretty much whole series, original sins included), the wasteland 2-3 dullfest, and an endless wasteland of minor stuff with clearly limited budget like some incomprehensible dungeon crawlers the codex like to sperg about.


holy crap i forgot outer fags, i'd put it beside oblivion, similar quality but into tiny instances filled with woke retardation.
 
Last edited:

Old One

Arcane
Joined
Jul 13, 2015
Messages
3,910
Location
The Great Underground Empire
NWN - I can't really lambast some of the great user-made modules, but on the other hand I find I can no longer play them because the base game is so bad. The OC is absolute trash. This is the champion, the single ugliest game ever made.

KOTOR2 - Ridiculous. The most overrated game on the Codex.
 

Erebus

Arcane
Joined
Jul 12, 2008
Messages
4,847
Most of the people who post in this thread seem to have had great luck when it comes to picking CRPGs. Either that, or they're younger than I thought the average Codexer was. I mean, NWN 1 OC was shit, but I'd count myself lucky if it had been anywhere close to being the worst CRPG I've ever played.

The truth is that most of the really bad CRPGs are fairly old. The newer ones have learned from the many mistakes that were made in earlier times. They can be extremely mediocre, but being truly godawful is usually beyond them.


Here's my list, in no particular order :


- Dragons of Flame
Looking back, Heroes of the Lance wasn't exactly a great game. But at least, it was playable. Its sequel throws unending waves of enemies in your face and you can only fight them with a single hero at a time even though your party has at least 8 members !

- Hillsfar
Minigames are not uncommon in CRPGS. Some of them are good. Some of them are bad, but you can usually ignore them or at least spend very little time on them. But Hillsfar... ah, Hillsfar is ONLY made of minigames. And they ALL suck.

- Pool of Radiance : Ruins of Myth Drannor
Whoever designed this game was actually trying to make it as annoying and boring as possible, it's the only explanation I can come up with.

- Ishar 2
The first one was a poor imitation of Might & Magic, but it was playable. The second one is buggy and it makes the psychology system even worse than it was before.

- B.A.T II : The Koshan Conspiracy
Attention to details is a virtue, but this game will try very hard to convince you otherwise.
 

As an Amazon Associate, rpgcodex.net earns from qualifying purchases.
Back
Top Bottom