Elwro
Arcane
If you're saying that the 'logical' way of playing involves blocking both ring slots and not having fast roll, then I guess we can agree that 'logical', the way you're using that term (not sure why though) doesn't equal 'fun' or 'smart' or 'interesting' and that's it.
Also, what you're describing seems to lead to a really risk-averse style of gameplay. To come back to my previous example, to maximize miracle damage I use Gwyndolin's crown and RotSF. I risk being hit more but the increased damage output is worth it... for me, that's a personal preference. That using a certain setup trivialises the game for those people who like their game to be boring doesn't mean there's a real problem there.
And I think the game should offer a build like that, just for those players who hold a personal grudge towards some bosses who killed them hundreds of times.
Also, what you're describing seems to lead to a really risk-averse style of gameplay. To come back to my previous example, to maximize miracle damage I use Gwyndolin's crown and RotSF. I risk being hit more but the increased damage output is worth it... for me, that's a personal preference. That using a certain setup trivialises the game for those people who like their game to be boring doesn't mean there's a real problem there.
And I think the game should offer a build like that, just for those players who hold a personal grudge towards some bosses who killed them hundreds of times.