Penalties from switching to a new guild and learning new abilities
Do you like the XP penalties in the game?
My saris Thief named "Sneaky" is a level 357 Thief.
Total XP = 24,050,139. No other guilds yet. He has 761 hitpoints, so no complaints about not taking the maximum hitpoint route.
He needs 135,199 XP and 88,538 gold for the next level. So approximately 270K XP and 180K gold for a pin run.
He has no guild penalties whatsoever.
I decided to take 5 Cleric levels, because I can use the healing and I've got the missing treatises for the first spells, and therefore can take notes of spell progression.
The first spells Cleric learns are:
Only 3 treatises needed for the first 10 spells. See: Cleric Spells
The Cleric guild has a penalty of 1.5 from all the Thief levels. <Shrugs> ok I can live with that.
But now I return to the Thief Guild because I need more time to find the other Cleric missing spellbooks.
Just from joining the Cleric guild, the Thief guild received a 0.01 penalty.
After gaining the first 5 levels, the penalty remains at 0.01.
Marginal, you might think, just a 1% penalty, but......
The penalty doesn't just apply to making new levels, the penalty applies back to Thief level 1.
The game calculates how much total XP you need with a 0.01 penalty and subtracts the XP already made to present you with the XP you need to make for the next level.
One big pile of XP to burn off.
Why? I didn't have any Cleric skills for 357 levels, so why take the penalty back to Thief level 1?
I could live with a penalty of 0.01 applied to the 135,199 XP I previously needed to make. That would come down to 136,551 XP.
But instead the game punishes me with 377,052 XP just for the next level.
Imagine I wouldn't come back so soon to the Thief guild but instead had built up a penalty of 0.25.
Then I would need to make approximately 6,147,733 XP. And in one level to be able to progress. All the penalty in one big pile.
Why? That discourages people to come back to a previous guild.
My two cents...
Penalties are fine, but not retroactive.
Apply the penalty to the Cleric levels. Ok.
Apply the penalty to the new Thief levels (358 and beyond). Ok.
But NOT to Thief levels 1 - 357!