I've said more than once that From quest design is shit. You just happened to pick elements that weren't. People who are reasonably intelligent have concepts of nuance and discussions that aren't taking extreme positions. Then there are guys like you two.
>dialogue clearly pointing in one direction as far as 99% of players are concerned
>actual content pointing at another (semi-random) direction entirely
>"yoU jUST dONt UNDersTaND NuanCE iN DIAlOguE"
Just go suck Miyazaki's dick, we all see it's your life's #1 ambition.