FeelTheRads said:
how the fuck is he right?
He's right in that before Bethesda released Fallout 3 everybody was screaming how it will suck, but now that we're talking about Obsidian suddenly we have to wait for the game to come out to bash it. Exactly what TESFers were saying.
And really, besides the shit things Bethesda was telling us that will be in Fallout 3 they also said some good things, but nobody cared about those. Of course, in the end they were lies, but for what reason should we trust Obsidian to not lie?
Track record?
First, Bethesda has been dumbing games down and shown little interest in getting good writers/designers. Like that quote: "Dialogue wasn't a battle we wanted to pick. There were other things that were more important for us to spend time and energy on… we just don't have unlimited monkeys and typewriters."
Second, Bethesda has a proven record of lying. It's kind of hard to think of a less trustworthy developer.
When Fallout 3's details and screens started hitting the net, it was clear that the overall design, setting, and dialogues were fucking stupid (as expected based on the track record), hence the reaction.
As for Obsidian, they have a much better track record (even SoZ shows willingness to experiment and try new things, which is probably one of the most important qualities in a game developer), I don't recall them lying and making shit up, but I do remember them publicly admitting that NWN2 was a 7/10 game. They do have good writers (MotB), they know how to work with dialogues and what role-playing is all about, and the key people worked on Fallout 2 and Van Buren, which makes them a much better choice than Bethesda.
Because it's an expansion, there is less pressure to flirt with the casual market on them (the MotB effect), so theoretically they are free to make whatever they want. Because they have the engine and the assets, they are free to focus on the gameplay, which inspires much confidence.
It doesn't mean that it will surely be an awesome game, but there is definitely no reason to be skeptical about it (unless I missed something, in which case feel free to point it out).