All this political scheming is just too awesome. Based on this, I pretty much MUST change my vote to C. A Shulgi-like politician who is actually Ean in an Empire where plots and schemes trump everything? We have to vote for the nobleman, bros.
The problem with our decision-making is in the very nature of the LP. We're a democracy, we're a committee, we cannot into long-term decision-making, just like real world governments. This is why monarchy is the best choice.
God save the Queen.
We were fine with long-term decisions regarding empire building until we saw the rift. Yes, we are many people with different ideas, but we can make that work for us too.
The problem with the last chapter was that people encountered an obstacle with no easy solution, and they got impatient, so they jumped in without thinking things through. Then they were caught off guard by the "WTF?" nature of the rift, so they voted for sphere diplomacy because they were thinking of events based on "oh shit what do I do?" rather than "how are we going to handle this situation?" We are going to have to react to events at times because unexpected shit is going to pop up all the time, but we should always keep in mind the long-term implications of what we're doing.
Regarding all those choices that surprised treave: the funny thing is, I never voted for a single one of them. My rationale when it comes to voting is pretty simple, I just try to think one step ahead. I thought "well, if we go into the rift we're still alone, outnumbered and without any idea about where to find Vajra, so we're still screwed anyways because we have no idea about how to achieve our goal. Because we have no plan, let's gamble on Vajra and hopefully it'll work out." Sure, that wasn't much of a plan either, but a gamble with the possibility of success had a higher chance of working out than a trip into the rift.
The gist of it is that I saw a way that using Vajra could work in our favour and many ways it could fail, but I saw many ways that a trip into the rift would fail, but no way that it could succeed.
Well, usually
Esquilax is influential enough to sway our votes? Perhaps you only need to push it a little bit more?
Or hey, you guys could avoid the perils of democracy by giving me veto power FOREVAR! I MUST SAVE YOU FROM YOURSELVES, CODEX!!!
Anyways, I pushed pretty hard at the time and I still wasn't able to sway your votes when it really mattered. People became really cautious when it came to anything relating to Vajra after the Zeus incident, so convincing the voters would have been very hard. To make things work, I propose the following set of guidelines for people involved in the DISCUSS!!! here:
- What's your goal? Right now it's "recover our memories without getting discovered by the spheres within the void." We should have joined up with the Masters, because that would have given us far more ability to understand them and thwart their plans, but what's done is done.
- No baseless speculation. That means you, Baltika9. If you provide a theory of some sort, back it up with quotes or reasoning.
- When you're voting, don't just tell me why you're voting for a particular choice. Tell me what you're going to do for the choice after that. So for example: "Hey, let's jump into the rift!", or "let's go for sphere diplomacy" OK, fine, but then what? What do you plan on doing once you've gone through the rift? You want to talk with the spheres, fine... but then what?
- When somebody says "hey, maybe we're in over our heads and we should run away from this dangerous encounter" don't refute their arguments with some variation of "YOU'RE A PUSSY/COWARD!!! FIGHT LIKE A MAN, GODDAMNIT!" Seriously, I hate this shit. It can come off as emotionally manipulative and it works too well in swaying votes, so cut that shit out.
To highlight this, let's look at a good decision we made at the end of Chapter 5, where we managed to narrowly escape permadeath. We realized that jumping into the fray wasn't a guarantee that we'd be able to stop Marduk/Zeus (like I said, we could step in... but then what?), and we didn't have a huge fucking ego about not being some ridiculous he-man who fights regardless of the circumstances. Likewise, zapping Marduk wasn't too bright because we already
had a plan to take him out with Edem, so we had the "but then what?" aspect covered.
Also, I'd like to make one request.
treave, I love the amazing pace you've been able to pull off here, and I don't want to come off as ungrateful given how much of this good shit you've spoiled us with, but when we get a crucial choice with lots of long-term implications (i.e. the choice at the rift, sphere diplomacy choice) could we have an extra day to think about it?
Perhaps it wouldn't have changed anything, but then again, people might have come to their senses too.