Yosharian
Arcane
Alright Grunker let me try and clarify a few things.
You wish to play a character that is suboptimal in order to preserve a level of challenge in the game and also feed your desire to create something 'unique' and/or 'unusual'. I get that. I found in my Kingmaker playthrough that I had created a team so powerful that nothing in the game presented any level of challenge, even with mods upping monster stats to ridiculous levels. So I do get it.
My view is that, by opting out of weapons entirely and only using natural attacks, you are already creating a pretty decent level of challenge. You are opting out of the crazy on-hit/on-crit effects that weapons can bring, opting out of absurd crit ranges e.g. fauchard, scimitar, and so on. That, to me, is enough of a handicap that you don't need to opt out of any other things, like BFT or Skald and so on.
But it seems that you aren't happy with only taking natural attacks, you also want to opt out of taking the best support classes in the game to back you. In this case I'm not sure how to help you because I can't see into your brain and determine what will and what won't go beyond what you consider acceptable. I am a player that tends to enjoy optimizing things to the maximum as that's the 'puzzle' that I enjoy solving, if you like.
So I can only point out the things that I think are suboptimal and suggest improvements to those areas, tbh.
BTW I am not calling you an idiot and I'm sure Hap isn't either, we are just trying to understand what you're going for and it's a little puzzling =)
You wish to play a character that is suboptimal in order to preserve a level of challenge in the game and also feed your desire to create something 'unique' and/or 'unusual'. I get that. I found in my Kingmaker playthrough that I had created a team so powerful that nothing in the game presented any level of challenge, even with mods upping monster stats to ridiculous levels. So I do get it.
My view is that, by opting out of weapons entirely and only using natural attacks, you are already creating a pretty decent level of challenge. You are opting out of the crazy on-hit/on-crit effects that weapons can bring, opting out of absurd crit ranges e.g. fauchard, scimitar, and so on. That, to me, is enough of a handicap that you don't need to opt out of any other things, like BFT or Skald and so on.
But it seems that you aren't happy with only taking natural attacks, you also want to opt out of taking the best support classes in the game to back you. In this case I'm not sure how to help you because I can't see into your brain and determine what will and what won't go beyond what you consider acceptable. I am a player that tends to enjoy optimizing things to the maximum as that's the 'puzzle' that I enjoy solving, if you like.
So I can only point out the things that I think are suboptimal and suggest improvements to those areas, tbh.
BTW I am not calling you an idiot and I'm sure Hap isn't either, we are just trying to understand what you're going for and it's a little puzzling =)