Nah, fuck it I'm getting this (pleb edition of course). If zoomers, bottom-feeding youtubers, and journos hate it there might be something decent here.
Seriously though, some of the criticism is pretty questionable e.g. one reviewer slighted it for not offering neo pronouns, and a few have complained that abilities require perks to unlock. In other words, they hate that you can't do everything, as in Skyrim. But, for me that's reminiscent of Daggerfall (best ES game) where my nightblade is never ever going to wear chain or plate, and magic is best used to turn invisible for 20 secs, backstab and then fall back to the shadows. I can't be an archmage, or warrior, because I didn't pick either of those classes, but I can use magic to supplement my core combat and stealth skills. The strengths and weaknesses of my character, what he can and cannot do, dictate how I play. How can you complain about that in an RPG?
The other big gripes are 'immersion', and that the presence of loading screens implies that things like planets and their surface areas aren't 'really there', or not legitimiate in some undefined way. I mean, it's weird that starfield has provoked these kind of questions about how games are made, but nothing is 'really there' in any game. If I'm stood in whiterun, the rest of skyrim isn't 'really there'. Even so-called 'seamless' traversal across skyrim involves instantiating about 4 cells around my character, loading a new one in front, and unloading another behind. So the difference between actively loading/unloading cells, and having a blunt 'loading' screen is an aesthetic and not material distinction. If this reality fatally injures immersion I hope these people never find out about occlusion culling, and that everything and anything, including their immersive 4k horse shit, is instantly annihilated when out of sight and was never really there to begin with.
I get it that developers should somewhat obfuscate these realities in order to sustain a suspension of disbelief, and maybe Starfield is peculiarly clumsy in how it does this, but these complaints are applying an unusual standard.