Tempest Rising - totally not Command & Conquer clone from 3D Realms

[Cyberarmy]

I can see it, definitely not Hell March

 

[thesheeep]

Grimoire - too expensive
Underrail - took too long to ship
now this game is "totally not a clone" (yet everyone in the thread seems to like it)

I mean, they are obviously playing with being a clone.
Being a clone is not necessarily a bad thing - especially not a clone of a good thing!

Overreacting, much?

 

[luj1]

Being a clone is not necessarily a bad thing - especially not a clone of a good thing!

ofc

 

[Feyd Rautha]

I will buy it! Looks like the the third faction will be aliens.

 

[Feyd Rautha]

Look at that Hand of Nod at 01:16!

 

[JarlFrank]

Look at that Hand of Nod at 01:16!

Definitely a nod towards C&C there!

 

[Curratum]

Slipgate Ironworks and 3D Realms are scammers of the highest caliber. I wouldn't touch anything they ever claim they are going to put out.

 

[Suicidal]

I want this to be good

 

[Feyd Rautha]

Look at that Hand of Nod at 01:16!

Definitely a nod towards C&C there!

The alien Tempest Vines that they harvest as a recource is a crystal clear nod as well.

 

[Lim-Dûl]

Spoiler

She is cute as fuck. I will buy this game.

 

[ArchAngel]

If this game is really good it might force me to finally install shitty Win10 on my PC.

 

[Parsimonious cook]

Damn bro a C&C-like in this day and age?

 

[80s Stallone]

Dreamt of something like this for years, but they clearly based it on Tiberium Wars / Red Alert 3.

My gripes:
- this sort of 3D where the whole map is cluttered with stuff is too confusing in strategy games, keep it simple.
- like most 3D RTS there is no "felt" impact in the battles, it's like rubber or cardboard stuff shooting at each other, either make it nice 2(.5)D (not likely for non-indie) or find a way
- secondary abilities for most units... just no. that's not classic C&C. Down with micro.
- GDF, Destiny? Those names are pretty lame... GDI sounds cool, but GDF? C'mon, come up with something else, it does not flow. Destiny? Eeek. Dumb name for a faction.

Otherwise, good luck.

 

[Trithne]

Dreamt of something like this for years, but they clearly based it on Tiberium Wars / Red Alert 3.

My gripes:
- this sort of 3D where the whole map is cluttered with stuff is too confusing in strategy games, keep it simple.
- like most 3D RTS there is no "felt" impact in the battles, it's like rubber or cardboard stuff shooting at each other, either make it nice 2(.5)D (not likely for non-indie) or find a way
- secondary abilities for most units... just no. that's not classic C&C. Down with micro.
- GDF, Destiny? Those names are pretty lame... GDI sounds cool, but GDF? C'mon, come up with something else, it does not flow. Destiny? Eeek. Dumb name for a faction.

Otherwise, good luck.

Good thing it's called the Tempest Dynasty then.

 

[80s Stallone]

Dreamt of something like this for years, but they clearly based it on Tiberium Wars / Red Alert 3.

My gripes:
- this sort of 3D where the whole map is cluttered with stuff is too confusing in strategy games, keep it simple.
- like most 3D RTS there is no "felt" impact in the battles, it's like rubber or cardboard stuff shooting at each other, either make it nice 2(.5)D (not likely for non-indie) or find a way
- secondary abilities for most units... just no. that's not classic C&C. Down with micro.
- GDF, Destiny? Those names are pretty lame... GDI sounds cool, but GDF? C'mon, come up with something else, it does not flow. Destiny? Eeek. Dumb name for a faction.

Otherwise, good luck.

Good thing it's called the Tempest Dynasty then.

ah yes. Still lame.

 

[gurugeorge]

It's very tempting and exciting, but from these clips I worry about the readability of the graphics.

These games worked partly because objects were easily recognizable and distinct on the playing field, so you didn't have to waste brain energy on peering at things to identify them; if it's going to be like a visual soup it's not going to be so good.

I mean, this is the same problem with a lot of modern games with great graphics, getting the right balance between detailed, realistic graphics vs. gameplay readability - although many developers are aware of it, some still seem to be oblivious. Hope these guys understand.

 

[Harthwain]

I am getting strong Emperor: Battle for Dune vibes from this for some reason. I am going to watch with interest.

 

[Curious_Tongue]

- this sort of 3D where the whole map is cluttered with stuff is too confusing in strategy games, keep it simple.

Depends.

Tiberium Sun, Red Alert 2 and 3 and C&C3 had a lot going on on the map that was interesting or added to the gameplay without being confusing.

 

[Feyd Rautha]

Here's a good video breakdown of what has been shown so far.

 

[geno]

Gameplay with a whole mission and the unbiased commentary from the CEO of 3D Realms:

 

[ArchAngel]

It is really bugging me that tank is way too small compared to standard troopers.

 

[Harthwain]

Gameplay with a whole mission and the unbiased commentary from the CEO of 3D Realms:

No breakdown on what games they are showing whatsoever on their YouTube channel? These guys are amateurs. I was curious about some other games too, but the video is such an unedited mess that I won't even bother.

It is really bugging me that tank is way too small compared to standard troopers.

I'd say the ratio is similar (if not identical) to the likes of Red Alert 2 or Emperor: Battle for Dune.

 

[Feyd Rautha]

It is really bugging me that tank is way too small compared to standard troopers.

I'd say the ratio issimilar (if not identical) to the likes of Red Alert 2 or Emperor: Battle for Dune.

Yeah the original C&C had better scaling but already the first Red Alert had huge infantry.

 

[ArchAngel]

Gameplay with a whole mission and the unbiased commentary from the CEO of 3D Realms:

No breakdown on what games they are showing whatsoever on their YouTube channel? These guys are amateurs. I was curious about some other games too, but the video is such an unedited mess that I won't even bother.

It is really bugging me that tank is way too small compared to standard troopers.

I'd say the ratio is similar (if not identical) to the likes of Red Alert 2 or Emperor: Battle for Dune.

Maybe but camera was further away and graphics were simple so it was not noticeable. And once you are spamming 20 tanks and 30 inf and sending them to battle you might ignore it but in campaign with one tank and 5 troopers it just stands out

 

[Feyd Rautha]

Gameplay with a whole mission and the unbiased commentary from the CEO of 3D Realms:

No breakdown on what games they are showing whatsoever on their YouTube channel? These guys are amateurs. I was curious about some other games too, but the video is such an unedited mess that I won't even bother.

It is really bugging me that tank is way too small compared to standard troopers.

I'd say the ratio is similar (if not identical) to the likes of Red Alert 2 or Emperor: Battle for Dune.

Maybe but camera was further away and graphics were simple so it was not noticeable. And once you are spamming 20 tanks and 30 inf and sending them to battle you might ignore it but in campaign with one tank and 5 troopers it just stands out

Yeah why is the camera always so close? Petroglyph got a lot of negative feedback on that already with Universe at War back in 2007. Have they learnt nothing since?