While I agree about reddit, I believe the Chaos Blade is the most unbalanced weapon right now. It simply deals way too much damage. It has absolutely everything, the best katana moveset, really good range, 150 counter modifier, etc. Way too much damage for such a fast weapon. If anything, the Bewitched Alonne Sword should have the highest damage, since it's slower than other katanas and has a harder to use moveset. I normally prefer weaker items being buffed to be on par of the good ones instead of having the good ones nerfed (like Reddit always wants) but in this case I agree that the Chaos Blade needs a nerf.
Also the "don't trade with it" thing is easy to say and do because most Chaos Blade users are extremely bad players looking for an easy win, but if you use it you know how easy it is to just press R1 at the right moment to get counters every time. I don't even need much precision in the timing, because many times my attacks get interrupted before they are anywhere near completion and the hitbox still comes out, causing trades.
On the topic of katanas, the Bewitched Alonne Sword really needs a buff. The sudoku lasts too little to be worth using, and the R1s have no tracking and are very hard to turn. I would love to be able to delay my swing and turn the R1 to the sides to catch people rolling to my back and such things, would make the weapon benefit more from skill, but sadly it is impossible, they barely turn at all.
--
The DLC images look good. I'm very curious to see what they do when you complete all the DLCs, if it's going to be just some item, a lore dump, a new ending, or what.