I have changed my mind about Two Worlds II a little bit. The intro really sucks - however, with tweaks and some leveling, once the game world opens, things change dramatically. There is some genuinely good quest design - for instance, in getting past a guard checkpoint, you have several options, from buying forgeries of official documents, to helping various people on side-quests around the village. The way that side-quests intertwine with one another and open new options is genuinely well done.
It's nothing revolutionary, but a lot better than I expected considering some of the early stuff. And some of the writing actually gets pretty good - some solid dialogue and voice acting, and *gasp* humour that was actually funny. I don't know exactly what happened by something about the game "clicked" for me past the starting area and now I'm enjoying it. It feels like it has a lot more heart to it than something like Skyrim, and just like the Gothic games, even with all the issues, that sense of personality gives the game a certain charm that keeps me interested.
Actually playing the game is still a bit awkward (like I said, combat and controls sort of suck, AI is near broken) but if you can stomach that, there are definitely things to like about the game - it's nowhere near as bad as I'd heard from others back when it came out. And of course, you could always just, you know, play Gothic II or Risen again, and have more fun. But whatever, for $10 I can't complain much.
As for Alan Wake - it's not terrible but it's one of those games where the ideas are much better than the execution. The first 2ish chapters are great - but after a while the plot falls apart and stops trying to make even a lick of sense, Alan isn't a very likeable protagonist, and the lack of variety in gameplay really starts to hurt. I finished it recently after a big break and it was just a chore for me to reach the end (which was supremely disappointing in the most impotent, stereotypical "cliffhanger, lol nothings resolved" kind of way). As much as I want to support Remedy, I really do wish I had waited until it was on sale.