KickStarter Underworld Ascendant Pre-Prototype Thread

[Melan]

That's always subject to change anyway.

 

[Metro]

Eh, I'll get excited when I see more substantive gameplay.

^

Do they have anything substantial aside of few concept art pieces and big names that were lost in time for long?

I wonder if this is worth backing - KS without at least some prototype proof of concept, with heavy use of names-dropping (Ultima this! Ultima that!) and dev team where the big names were out of the game for quite some time - makes me wary

Uh, but there is a prototype proof of concept.

But there's very little footage of it in the KS. Looks like a slightly prettier Arx but, again, going to need to see combat and character development, etc. Not just a dude hurling a fireball at a giant spider.

 

[Infinitron]

Well, they said there'll be more next week. Not sure if it will be enough for you but we'll see.

 

[Metro]

Not just me, apparently, because they seem to be stalling. It's one thing to invoke all of these games and another to show you have something that can deliver on what you promise. IMO, they jumped the gun. Either that, or they just did a poor job at putting together the initial video/pitch.

 

[Infinitron]

Not just me, apparently, because they seem to be stalling. It's one thing to invoke all of these games and another to show you have something that can deliver on what you promise. IMO, they jumped the gun. Either that, or they just did a poor job at putting together the initial video/pitch.

Their pitch wasn't bad. There are games that have done better with equal or worse pitches and campaigns. One of them is running a Kickstarter right now.

It just wasn't a very GOOD pitch either. You need to try much harder these days to grab people's attentions if you don't have an existing audience like Shadowrun does.

As for them stalling, pretty much every KS stalls at this point. Hopefully they won't slow down any further.

 

[mindx2]

I hope we hear from them soon about a friendly Codex visit so I can actually bring back something solid to show.

 

[Jaesun]

Voted!

 

[evdk]

It's on Greenlight: http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=391292833

Go vote for it, guys.

Oh, they're on Greenlight: http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=391292833

Vote 'em up!

Newsbot is slipping badly. Needs more RAM.

 

[Weirdstuffinspace]

I hope these guys don't get over exited with the big caverns they can make and remember to put some huge walls coming at you dungeons that just seem to go on forever in the dark.

 

[Infinitron]

UPDATE: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/othersidegames/underworld-ascendant/posts/1134398

We want to hear from You!

We’re doing a set of polls to get a better sense of who our fan community is and what they are looking for in the game. For instance, how interested are you in VR? Please go over to theforums.

Your input will help us better prioritize what we’re working on going forward. When we get to 500 fans having participated in the Polls, we promise we’ll do something silly. We’ve also made a new section for Fan Submissions in the forums.

Over the coming week, we cordially invite any of you who have played the original Underworld games to post in our forums fun stories around a memorable experience you had playing them. We’ll then select several to highlight with the community.

Ahem, there's a vote on co-op: http://www.othersideentertainment.com/forum/index.php?topic=169.0

 

[Metro]

Oh God... co-op and VR...

 

[veevoir]

Oh God... co-op and VR...

This is better:

Invite a friend to join you online for a cut of the loot. All your buddies’ offline? Use a Doppelganger Gem to borrow a friend's character as an invulnerable ethereal companion AI. Afterward, your friend will receive a message, with video highlights and rewards.

I already see it happening, video recorded during game, snipped and sent to the recipient. I want to love this KS but, such promises (and several other things they toy, including coop and VR) suggest a lot of people may be promised the moon and molyneux'd in the end.

I hope their updates during the days to come either turn off some of the red flags this is raising or confirm them.

 

[Infinitron]

Create an account on their forums and vote against those things. They're already losing, but the margin isn't as high as you'd like.

 

[veevoir]

Create an account on their forums and vote against those things. They're already losing, but the margin isn't as high as you'd like.

Definately.

But the fact devs have such ideas is worrisome in the first place. After KS ends we won't be always there to poll bomb any stupid idea presented to the masses.

 

[Infinitron]

Like I said, the Looking Glass guys are innovators first, nostalgists second. They're going to keep coming up with weird ideas, but one should hope they have the project management chops to cut features that have no chance of being successfully implemented.

 

[Metro]

Naga, please. Create an account to tell them wasting money on shit like coop and VR at the expense of content is a bad idea? That's like saying I have to tell someone slamming their nuts in a car door is a bad idea.

 

[xemous]

good luck!

 

[Melan]

Like I said, the Looking Glass guys are innovators first, nostalgists second. They're going to keep coming up with weird ideas, but one should hope they have the project management chops to cut features that have no chance of being successfully implemented.

Definitely, but promising coop as a stretch goal was not a good idea, because that's a promise to the people who pledged the money. They can cut it in development (if they reach that stretch goal) since KS funding isn't an enforcable contract, but it will come with a PR hit.

 

[Wirdschowerdn]

Kickstarter is a bubble in deflation mode due to abuse from hacks like Tim Schafer and Josh Sawyer's Infinite Dungeon: End of Fun shenanigans.

The Otherside folks should have jumped a lot earlier on the KS train when the novelty and credibility of it was still fresh.

 

[Infinitron]

Like I said, the Looking Glass guys are innovators first, nostalgists second. They're going to keep coming up with weird ideas, but one should hope they have the project management chops to cut features that have no chance of being successfully implemented.

Definitely, but promising coop as a stretch goal was not a good idea, because that's a promise to the people who pledged the money. They can cut it in development (if they reach that stretch goal) since KS funding isn't an enforcable contract, but it will come with a PR hit.

Heh, well, that's a big "if".

 

[General Maxson]

They are innovators? Why can't they innovate something good/single player gameplay oriented, without the stupid Co-op and VR shenanigans?

 

[Durante]

Oh God... co-op and VR...

VR seems like the logical next step for a company with Looking Glass' legacy.

It's the natural goal of immersive sims.

 

[Unkillable Cat]

I don't mind the VR, but the "co-opt a buddy" thing seems bizarre.

 

[Runciter]

I don't know why you all are afraid of them taking the risk. If they manage to pull co-op off, it will be glorious. I remember very fondly playing through Unreal with a couple of friends, it was much more fun than single player. The reward is worth it to me.

 

[yaster]

Like I said, the Looking Glass guys are innovators first, nostalgists second. They're going to keep coming up with weird ideas, but one should hope they have the project management chops to cut features that have no chance of being successfully implemented.

Definitely, but promising coop as a stretch goal was not a good idea, because that's a promise to the people who pledged the money. They can cut it in development (if they reach that stretch goal) since KS funding isn't an enforcable contract, but it will come with a PR hit.

Yeah, remember that humongous PR hit Larian got when they dropped Mega Dungeon, NPC Schedules and Day and Night Cycle. Now everybody and their dogs are saying that Original Sin's kickstarter was the worst! They bearly sold any copies of the game as a result!

I don't think Otherside would want to drop coop eitherway for different reasons thought.

As far as coop is concerned I have the same stance on it as I have on cardboard boxes or physical goods in general. I have no interest in either, they don't have influence on the core experience while both eat in the budget. But some people are just mad about them. Like really mad. And they are eager to pledge because of that. Seems like things that kickstarter does.