Mebber
Educated
- Joined
- Sep 7, 2012
- Messages
- 47
Juan_Carlo said:Thief 3 isn't bad.
Thief 3 is a mixed bag of some quite good ideas, rather bad executions of said ideas in some cases, and some serious gameplay annoyances.
Examples: The need to household with your stuff and money over the course of the entire game, not just a single mission? Cool! No need to be economical at all because you've looted enough after just a few missions to buy everything you could ever wish for? Boring. Exploring the city, including free looting, buying and selling crap? Great! Exploring a city that never changes a bit, with the exact same loot and guards respawning every night at the exact same location and where there isn't anything left to do after your first visit, turning large parts of the "free nights" into tedious routine? Not so much. Being hunted in the dark by assassin-guys who are supposed to be a real match for your stealth skills? Frightening! These guys wandering around the streets with no caution whatsoever, attacking everyone and being attacked by everyone, resulting in a giant, bloody, noisy mess which somehow even causes everyone who sees you to freak out because they automatically think you're the one responsible for all the shit? Not very good.
And for the gameplay, the controls are sluggish, really sluggish. In a game that takes (or should take) good portions of it's tension from precise, very well-timed movements, that's a pretty bad thing in my opinion. But since the game is pretty easy anyway you don't need good movement control anyway i guess. And while a few maps a quite good, most doesn't even come close in terms of level design quality compared to the predecessors.
Enjoyed the atmosphere, though. Robbing the cradle and spying on the keepers was intense.
I think it's only an average game on it's own terms, and a bad game compared to the other Thief titles. But tastes differ, i guess.