ebPD8PePfC
Savant
- Joined
- May 13, 2018
- Messages
- 225
Predynastic Egypt - it's a nice management game where you optimize a small system, with some Egyptian history stuff goes on in the background. It's cute, but lacks depth. If you enjoy min-maxing or Egyptian history than the game might be for you.
Egypt: Old Kingdom -The next game in the series. Adds some depth with a Civilization style buildings in provinces, more involved combat, as well as some RNG. The RNG suffers from the same issue as many crpgs, early on it's absolutely decisive while later on it's meaningless. On turn 3 I lost a worker to RNG, which would have taken me at least 10 turns to recovers from. After a restart I got 3 workers at random which would have taken me 20-30 turns to recruit on my own. At the later phases of the game when you have 70 workers these sort of events don't really matter, but early on they overshadow every other element of the game. Since I had good RNG early on, I maxed out all resources and explored the entire map by turn 100-120, and the game lasts 300 turns. I had nothing left to do for more than half of the game. The first game is definitely better.
I would add that the combat, while extremely primitive, does the job.
Egypt: Old Kingdom -The next game in the series. Adds some depth with a Civilization style buildings in provinces, more involved combat, as well as some RNG. The RNG suffers from the same issue as many crpgs, early on it's absolutely decisive while later on it's meaningless. On turn 3 I lost a worker to RNG, which would have taken me at least 10 turns to recovers from. After a restart I got 3 workers at random which would have taken me 20-30 turns to recruit on my own. At the later phases of the game when you have 70 workers these sort of events don't really matter, but early on they overshadow every other element of the game. Since I had good RNG early on, I maxed out all resources and explored the entire map by turn 100-120, and the game lasts 300 turns. I had nothing left to do for more than half of the game. The first game is definitely better.
I would add that the combat, while extremely primitive, does the job.