I found this post on Steam around the issues of inclusivity in KC:D2 and he makes very reasonable points and they seem historically accurate. I am not knowledgeable on this type of history but you dont need to be to agree with his points
I do think a game set in a historically accurate theme needs to be historically accurate. I am still going to play KC:D 2 but I can understand the criticism in this post
" I am getting tired of game developers caving to today’s “social norms” brought on by a small section of the gaming community. While diversity and representation are undoubtedly important in certain circumstances, it is essential to prioritize historical accuracy, especially in a game that aims to immerse players in a specific time period.
Kingdom Come Deliverance is known for its commitment to historical realism in its portrayal of 15th-century Bohemia. However, introducing characters from marginalized groups such as LGBTQ+ and darker skinned individuals into a prominent role in the game would undermine this dedication to authenticity.
Allow me to provide some historical context.
Bohemia in 1403 was a predominantly homologous society with limited diversity in terms of ethnicity and sexual orientation. LGBTQ+ and darker skinned people were not prominent or even acknowledged members of society during this time period. Introducing such characters into the game as anything other than background fodder would be historically inaccurate and would compromise the immersive experience that Kingdom Come Deliverance is renowned for providing.
Furthermore, Bohemia in the 15th century was deeply rooted in feudalism, with strict social hierarchies and cultural norms. Introducing characters who do not fit within these societal structures would not only be historically inaccurate but also unrealistic.
Yes Bohemia, specifically Kuttenberg, may have had a degree of cultural diversity in the 15th century due to its economic importance and influx of people from various regions, like merchants, craftsmen, and miners from different areas of Europe. However, the primary cultural influence would still have been Czech, reflecting the broader context of the Kingdom of Bohemia.
I understand there is some importance of inclusivity and representation in this game, but it should not come at the expense of historical accuracy, especially in a game like Kingdom Come Deliverance that prides itself on its realism.
!!Trigger Warning!! Instead of shoehorning diversity into the game and forcing a gay/trans character down our throats just because “WE NEED REPRESENTATION!”, I urge the development team to focus on telling an engaging and authentic story within the constraints of the historical context.
Before you flame me and call my homophobic or racist understand that I am all for including that kind of stuff in games that aren’t supposed to be historically accurate. Take BG3 as an example. I have over 140 hours in that game and it’s very diverse. However, it’s a fantasy game that isn’t rooted in any real-world events, history, or locations. "