Community Codex GOTY 2015 - Results

[Fairfax]

Dumb troll or not, this Pirata Alma Negra guy is the worst.
Some of his notable contributions:

Undertale: 5
Fallout 4: 5
Life is Feudal: 5
PoE: 5
AoD: 1
Underrail: 1
Shadowrun HK: 1
SoD YOSE: 5
SCL: 5
The Witcher 3: 5

 

[Tigranes]

Dumb troll or not, this Pirata Alma Negra guy is the worst.
Some of his notable contributions:

Undertale: 5
Fallout 4: 5
Life is Feudal: 5
PoE: 5
AoD: 1
Underrail: 1
Shadowrun HK: 1
SoD YOSE: 5
SCL: 5
The Witcher 3: 5

This cuts deeper than any Darth Roxor post could

 

[Ismaul]

Tag 'em so we can identify them!




hmm where's that Hitler smilie? Guess this will have to do:

 

[Jaesun]

Just watchwitz them

 

[Metro]

Don't think I voted. As an RPG I would give Fallout 4 a 0/5. As a fun FPS-ARPG-derpy game I'd give it a 2 or 3 out of 5. I'd give Undertale an Lolhipstershitcashgrab out of 5.

 

[ArchAngel]

Thanks, this is much better.

Has this been posted yet?

Users who gave Fallout 4 a 4/5:

• Dangersaurus
• matt
• Mortmal
• MZeta
• Nekot-The-Brave
• Pigiron
• Seerix
• Sky
• sstacks
• Themadcow
• ZodoZ

And just when he was starting to get Codex cool points with his whalenought interview..

sstacks what do you have to say in your defense?

 

[AwesomeButton]

Brethren! Sstacks has come to seduce us to the popamole ways! This cannot be allowed!

 

[Cazzeris]

I haven't even played the game.

Probably got UnderRail and this mixed up. Perhaps I should abstain from voting...

 

[Xzylvador]

I haven't even played the game.

Probably got UnderRail and this mixed up. Perhaps I should abstain from voting...

Understandable.

vs

They do look very much the same.

 

[Tacgnol]

Probably got UnderRail and this mixed up. Perhaps I should abstain from voting...

 

[Ellef]

If you're too brain damaged to vote in a poll without messing up, then undertale might be the game for you

 

[Irenaeus III]

At least he lives up to his avatar.

 

[laclongquan]

I like the 1300+ vote better. it make for so much drama~ This 700+ vote this year is duller in comparison.

 

[Fairfax]

Those who gave FO4 a 5/5 deserve a

tag, at the very least.

 

[Maculo]

Christ, I missed out on a lot of games. I need to give UR, SitSL, and AoD a shot. I had no clue that UR vs. AoD has become so contentious for some posters. The only thing this thread is missing is Hiver.

While I am glad that the Witcher 3 did alright, I did not expect it to make top 3. The combat was a complete slog, but I enjoyed the story and interactions.

Edit: Just looked at Felipes graph, a large group of people throw out 5s like its candy.

 

[Scroo]

Undertale in the bottom 10? I wonder how many butthurt ppl voted 1 point but never even touched it

 

[Irenaeus III]

Undertale in the bottom 10? I wonder how many butthurt ppl voted 1 point but never even touched it

Probably most of codex. I didn't touch the game, so no vote.

The rules for next year maybe could be expanded to include "vote 1 if you found the game so horrifying you didn't even touch it".

 

[Fairfax]

I did touch Undertale, and I hated it. The only games I didn't touch but gave a 1 were shitty ports, specially the ones with 30fps locks.

 

[Cazzeris]

They do look very much the same.

Where did I say it was the graphics that confused me, you idiot? I had already voted in a gazillion of polls, so the process had become totally meaningless to me at that point and the titles started to feel fuzzy.

 

[Xzylvador]

They do look very much the same.

Where did I say it was the graphics that confused me, you idiot?

Wow. Just... wow.




(Also: Are you sure you didn't play UnderTale?* It might explain the obvious brain damage.)

(*: In case you are once again confused, I am talking about the game that didn't win GOTY.)

 

[Cazzeris]

They do look very much the same.

Where did I say it was the graphics that confused me, you idiot?

Wow. Just... wow.

(Also: Are you sure you didn't play UnderTale?* It might explain the obvious brain damage.)

(*: In case you are once again confused, I am talking about the game that didn't win GOTY.)

Shit, sarcasm isn't easy to detect on the Internet, you know.

 

[commie]

i'd rather play through the poe expansion than underrail

I'm genuinely hard-pressed to identify rational reasons why you find the game so repugnant. Your opinions in the actual Underrail thread were gross oversimplifications, exaggerations, and nitpicking of the variety that can easily be used to lambast just about any game someone personally dislikes.

Well that was the same with his rage against PoE..

This is all exactly like fallout see its brown and post-apo and isometric and single-character! In that sense, it pisses me off exactly the same way PoE did - if not for the tards flooding the 'dex at its release saying that it's the second coming of bestestness, I wouldn't have given enough of a shit to respond with the Ultimate Review (tm).

So Roxor admits the review was all a giant troll. He's probably on his seventh playthrough as we speak!

 

[circ]

people are retarded and have shit taste news at 22

 

[Wayward Son]

Well, now that I know what the best game of 2015 was, time to go play Morrowind or Wizardry.

 

[naossano]

This poll is bullshit because Underrail was launched in December 2015 and therefore is pretty much a 2016 game.
What do I mean is:
Age of Decadence GOTY 2015
Underrail GOTY 2016 (or not, I did not play it yet because MY GODDAMN PC DECIDED TO DIE FUCK THE UNIVERSE)

Underrail release date is 2015 GOTY material. This isn't a rule, but the award often goes to the most recently released title. (any medium, any kind of jury)
Although, glad those titles went high. I also glad that the list of contestant made be discover so many titles. (sad that i don't even have time to play my A- list these days)