Darth Roxor said:
Clockwork Knight said:
These aren't choices at all, not even fake choices.
You have four dialogue lines to
choose that probably lead to the same motherfucking outcome. How is it not a choice (be it a minor one) and how is it not fake? Fake choices don't operate on a yes/no axis, and this is the same kind of fake choice as Mass Effect's 'WHAT DID U SEE SHEPARD!?!?!?! - (A) BIG TROUBLE, (B) OUR DEATH, (C) NOT QUITE CLEAR' and all of that leading to 'PPLZ SLAUGHTERIN' OTHER PPLZ'.
No, in Shep's case the options apparently lead to different dialogue, while in reality its all the same, you just got tricked. Here it's completely clear that you're going to say yes no matter what (I mean, just read the options). It's not a choice at all (so you may complain that you dont have a choice, but the game isn't pretending otherwise).
Some people here apparently prefer that the game just talks for you anyway if there's not a choice available, like it's more "honest" or something. I don't see any difference between it and the game just letting me choose the tone.
baronjohn said:
Drafting is still shit because when you meet the grey warden he swears to your father that he won't draft you. Then he drafts you the next morning.
Fuck, he lied to me
I mean, lying, who the fuck does that
.
But it's not presented as any kind of lie in the game world. Basically it goes like this
grey warden: I'm here to look for recruits
father: oh look here's my daughter... wait, you're not going to invoke the power of conscription are you? Because I don't want my only daughter to die a horrible death against the undead hordes.
grey warden: I swear to you I have no intention of conscribing anyone
father: OK
That's a lie, all right
then the next morning
grey warden: Wanna be a grey warden?
character: err, no
grey warden: Are you sure you don't wanna be a grey warden?
character: Look, I said no. Go away already.
grey warden: But you must help us!
character: I don't care if you all die. Now fuck off!
grey warden: Congratulations, you're now a grey warden
character: great, lets go!
father, dying: have a good trip!
I don't think you can say "no" to
compulsory enrollment...the character does seem schizo, but whatever
Metalcraze said:
Yes - and that's what makes the moment crappier - typical Bioware. Waterchip worked because "son we are gonna die, you gotta find the chip" and it didn't feel forced.
I didn't play it, but I'm guessing "son, we are gonna die, shitload of darkspawn incoming, help us" could also be some excuse. Can't vow for it, though.
We are talking about Fallouts not Bethesda shit
In Fallout 1 your guy lived in the vault before the game started. 3 is the same thing, only they feel like showing you for some reason. 1 just skipped the whole process of they deciding what the fuck they should do.
Oh really - what if I don't want to be a fucking jedi all over again?
Ah sorry I forgot this is a LARPer's game - you must pretend like things matter to your character.
You mean ignoring the main quest and keep doing sidequests forever like it's freedom of choice or something?
Also, I just got this amusing mental image of someone playing Mario and suddenly deciding they don't want to save the princess at all