RGE
Liturgist
Are you suggesting that The Sims was a random hit and not the result of someone being smart enough to know what would sell? I'd say that when someone finds an untapped market and cashes in on it, they're "doing their job right". It doesn't matter if they didn't know how well it would sell either, because the success still depended upon them doing their job right. Unpredictable for most people perhaps, but the job still has to be done right, whether that job is to program a game or to come up with the idea for a game.MarFish said:You make it sound like super hits are random, unpredictable events and not the work of people doing their job right. Sometimes (The Sims) that might be the case ...
As for Troika's reputation, I think that it matters most to would-be publishers and not so much to would-be customers. Word may get around, but as far as I know the internet gaming community is small compared to the amount of customers. I suppose a larger minority (maybe even a majority) read reviews, so when mainstream review sources mention the reputation of a developer it might count for something.