KickStarter Pathologic 2 (AKA Pathologic remake)

[kain30]

zed, read this three reviews of pathologic by RPS, and you will see http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2008/04/10/butchering-pathologic-part-1-the-body/

 

[Konjad]

I didn't like The Void. Is this game better?

Way better. but i won't go into details now, for my full opinion, read my review

 

[Perkel]

I didn't like The Void. Is this game better?

Way better. but i won't go into details now, for my full opinion, read my review

It's different game. Especially game play wise

Though underlying themes are more or less the same. Fighting with unknown, uncovering information, deciding what is true without game telling you what is right answer.

So if he didn't like story/themese/dialogs etc he won't probably like it. If it was gameplay then there is big chance he will like it.

 

[Whisky]

Fuck yeah!

I'm going to wait until near the end to donate. I'm tempted to get a poster as an add-on, but I want to see what they are first. Since it's Pathologic it has a huge chance of being badass.

New playable characters as stretch goal are confirmed.

Where did you see that on the Kickstarter page? I can't seem to find it.

 

[Sordid MCA/Prosper Hybryd]

So if he didn't like story/themese/dialogs etc he won't probably like it.

Probably but not necessary.

The Void is much more abstract, pretentious and artsy-fartsy. Its story is too vague, too open to interpretation

There is a lot of layers in Pathologic story as well. It can be interpreted as a dialogue between player and author or as a parable, but at the same time you can perceive it just as a good mystical story about plague in provincial town if you don't like all this sophisticated stuff.

Where did you see that on the Kickstarter page? I can't seem to find it.

It's in comments.

 

[Whisky]

So if he didn't like story/themese/dialogs etc he won't probably like it.

Probably but not necessary.

The Void is much more abstract, pretentious and artsy-fartsy. Its story is too vague, too open to interpretation

There is a lot of layers in Pathologic story as well. It can be interpreted as a dialogue between player and author or as a parable, but at the same time you can perceive it just as a good mystical story about plague in provincial town if you don't like all this sophisticated stuff.

Where did you see that on the Kickstarter page? I can't seem to find it.

It's in comments.

Nice. There were supposed to be two more playable characters originally. I really hope they add them.

It should be noted that in the original English translation Pathologic becomes very, very vague and open to interpretation. It's a very interesting bad translation.

 

[Gragt]

The Void is much more abstract, pretentious and artsy-fartsy.

It ain’t abstract when it is grounded in reality, pretentious when it succeeds, or artsy-fartsy when it got actual content.

Its story is too vague, too open to interpretation

While open to interpretation, it is fairly well delienated. It isn’t one of these instances where “you can see everything you want in it”, and where there is likely nothing to see, because it simply doesn’t allow you to in the first place. Think of The Prisoner or L'année dernière à Marienbad.[/QUOTE]

 

[Perkel]

I wrote a bit on The Void in other thread. It is fantastic game because it doesn't provide an answer. You have what you have and you interpret it and game doesn't answer if your interpretation is right. What is more interesting is that game is actively trying to hide things and confuse you. So in the end you have entirely your own imagination of what this world presents, who is right who is wrong.

To this day i don't know any game that is so mature in its writing as it makes you actually think for yourself instead of looking for answer provided by developers. IT's kind of a "thing" that literally only game can provide as this is only possible through player interaction which is non existent in other media forms. It's absolutely ridden out of any story bias beside first sister.

edit:

I think i will do LP of The Void.

 

[oscar]

I'm almost worried a 'good' translation would take away from this game.

 

[Perkel]

I'm almost worried a 'good' translation would take away from this game.

I don't understand this comment. How not having shitty translation can degrade game ? Isn't that textbook Stockholm syndrome ?

 

[Zed]

maybe I'll give the original a spin. maybe I'll read konjad's review too. or maybe just read the review.

How not having shitty translation can degrade game ?

that's a funny sentence

Isn't that textbook Stockholm syndrome ?

not at all

 

[felipepepe]

The weird sentences went along well with the weird atmosphere, IMHO... almost like the Plague was breaking their minds.

 

[Konjad]

maybe I'll give the original a spin. maybe I'll read konjad's review too. or maybe just read the review.

Are you saying you'd rather go read RPS review than mine? Well, fuck off then. I can be called a faggot and a retard, but saying I'm worse than RPS tards is a serious offence. We are no bros.

 

[Brother None]

That's my boss

The weird sentences went along well with the weird atmosphere, IMHO... almost like the Plague was breaking their minds.

and it sometimes left things more open to interpretation. It really was interesting to see how that worked together to the better for this game, but from Ice-Pick's perspective I can certainly understand a need to get it fixed.

maybe I'll give the original a spin. maybe I'll read konjad's review too. or maybe just read the review.

Are you saying you'd rather go read RPS review than mine? Well, fuck off then. I can be called a faggot and a retard, but saying I'm worse than RPS tards is a serious offence. We are no bros.

To be fair that RPS writeup is really good. The best writing they ever published (done by a guest writer IIRC?)

 

[Zed]

maybe I'll give the original a spin. maybe I'll read konjad's review too. or maybe just read the review.

Are you saying you'd rather go read RPS review than mine? Well, fuck off then. I can be called a faggot and a retard, but saying I'm worse than RPS tards is a serious offence. We are no bros.

I never once mentioned RPS. But since we're no longer bros, I will not read your faggot & retard review.

 

[Castanova]

I donated. I doubt very much it'll be better than the original but I'm still really interested in seeing how it turns out.

 

[Perkel]

How not having shitty translation can degrade game ?

that's a funny sentence

Do you mean it adds to my char mysticism ? Am i better because of it ?
/s

Do you see my point ?

 

[Malpercio]

I didn't like The Void. Is this game better?

It's a shitty walking simulator with slow-ass walking speed and shitty forced "survival" mechanics. Interesting setting, though. Too bad it's almost unplayable. Hopefully the remake will fix that.

 

[oscar]

It enhanced the feeling we're in some weird Russian provincial backwater what makes sense as our characters are outsiders.

A lot of the dialogue was also quite beautiful and poetic due to the subtle 'offness' of how everyone speaks. On the whole I liked it even if was at the occasional expense of clarity.

There's no shortage of games with clear but dull prose.

 

[MuscleSpark]

Backed of course but

Exclusive In-Game Item
Kickstarter-Exclusive In-Game Event

I guess I'd prefer :incloosive: in this case.

Yeah, $100 pre-pre-order exclusive DLC is kinda shitty.

 

[Sordid MCA/Prosper Hybryd]

High-Resolution screenshots

Spoiler

There is also a great interview with Nikolai Dybowsky on RU.IGN but it's only in Russian.

 

[Whisky]

It enhanced the feeling we're in some weird Russian provincial backwater what makes sense as our characters are outsiders.

A lot of the dialogue was also quite beautiful and poetic due to the subtle 'offness' of how everyone speaks. On the whole I liked it even if was at the occasional expense of clarity.

There's no shortage of games with clear but dull prose.

Yeah, that was the interesting part of the translation. Sometimes it made characters sound like they were hiding something because of how longwinded and evasive the translation made them sound.

Of course, there were serious mistakes in the translation especially during the Devoutress's chapter (I think it was hers at least).

 

[ColCol]

So, should I play the original. I was waiting to play because I heard the translation was shit (and there was at one time a fan translation coming). Now, I might wait until the remake comes out. Suggestions?

 

[opium fiend]

I never finished the original, I think I'll play it with bachelor and haruspicus and then wait for the remake to do the devotress and what other characters they introduce.

The remake looks really good but the original simply oozes atmosphere

 

[Explorerbc]

I don't know how to put it, but those new screenshots give me a weird feeling, like they are too ... "clean" or something ?