Do you watch any movies from the black & white era? Why not?
what about if they were remastered w/ color? Still likely not eh?
For games it's a completely different situation as old games (not just RPGs) are considerably better, but this should help visualize the mentality.
Not only is the visual experience a major factor, the other is it is actually quite an esoteric understanding that old games are better, even if it is objective truth (which it is).
To understand that old games are generally better, you have to meet the following criteria:
1. Most importantly, have played A LOT of old games. Preferably across the entire spectrum (PC, Consoles, to a lesser extent handheld).
2. Ideally, were alive and gaming in the golden age (1990-2005 or so). Why this in addition to point #1? Because certain standards, such as level of tolerance for the less finer aspects of old school gaming (e.g imperfect controls), were not formed yet. A classic can be utterly monocled across the board and yet have non-standard controls which can present itself as a major roadblock going in with a modern perspective.
3. Not be a sissy cuck bitch. Old games are largely better because of gameplay design. Other things too, but gameplay was largely the big one. If you are a storyfaggot or graphics whore, older games don't exactly jump out. Sure older stories are generally also better, but modern ones are fully animated and voice acted, and older games often feature numerous "barriers" to bypass to enjoy their story, such as gameplay that actually demands something of the player. This should not be a barrier in the first place, but some men are mentally defect. Why the fuck would you play a game if you don't hold gameplay in the highest regard, as it is what makes up the majority of a game's running time. Clearly, no self-respect; don't value their own time.
The odds are slim for gen Z to see the light. In addition to older graphics and certain obstacles such as controls, they also have to bypass:
-To have the critical thinking ability to sense something is very, very wrong with most modern games
-To be open minded and hear other people when they point you to older games (of which there are not many hardcore gaming elders to steer the younguns correct). It is natural thinking to assume new > old, if there isn't an influence to show you otherwise.
-To not fall for peer pressure (all their friends are playing GTAV, Fortnite and Minecraft).
-The media machine. Game journos. Game events. Game marketing. None of this says old > new. Because that would not benefit the industry of course.
-To overcome their overall conditioning, having grown up with absolute sellout trash across the board, not just games: reality TV, dumb internet fads, retarded influencers, participation awards, mobile gaming, social media decline, modern Hollywood and so forth. Absolute decline.
-A large portion of Millenials and Gen X actually think modern > classic too. Straight-up retards. Even many on this very forum. There is no escaping these imbeciles they're everywhere. I don't blame gen z too much, they simply don't know better. But older generations should. If they don't they should hand in their gaming card, they're a disgrace to the absolute art achieved with classic gaming. I hate that I have to share a space with them if I want to talk gaming.
Most older games have terrible gameplay.
Completely, utterly wrong, imbecile. Hand in your gaming card, you failed the lore check.
Worst offenders are IE games. wtf is RTwP? You either go full real time or turn-based. It's obvious they were trying to get the Command and Conquer audience. Why would Zoomers play such outdated games when many better ones are available?
Now that is true to some extent, but IE games don't make up "most older games", they make up 0.001% of older games.