Old One
Arcane
How confident are you this is 100% true? Like I said, just created two characters with all skills maxed, played both games in parallel, answered all the questions in the same way (as much as you can answer the same way with a Malkavian and a Brujah), and got a different outcome.Which means your answers in all the dialogs with them before the final confrontation. Bloodlines is a game were earlier choices do matter sometimes !The way they react depends on their disposition which is negatively or positively affected by your dialog choices.
Both characters:
freed Lily, but made her mad by asking for money
found a replacement for Lily
did not piss off Big Cal
used every Seduction line with Jeanette
sucked up to Therese and didn't piss her off
refused to give the amulet to Jeanette
slashed the paintings and stole the cash box
gave the amulet to Therese
Brujah character: Therese furious (she called my character a worthless bag of something-or-other), impossible to save both sisters. Persuasion lines don't even appear.
Malkavian: "normal" dialogue lines making it easy to save both using Persuasion.
freed Lily, but made her mad by asking for money
found a replacement for Lily
did not piss off Big Cal
used every Seduction line with Jeanette
sucked up to Therese and didn't piss her off
refused to give the amulet to Jeanette
slashed the paintings and stole the cash box
gave the amulet to Therese
Brujah character: Therese furious (she called my character a worthless bag of something-or-other), impossible to save both sisters. Persuasion lines don't even appear.
Malkavian: "normal" dialogue lines making it easy to save both using Persuasion.