No - Saint's Row started off as a GTA knockoff, but has evolved essentially into what GTA should have been: Fun. Saint's Row 2 came out about the same time as GTA IV - which game would you rather play?Saint's Row has always been bad
SR kept going over the top, adding more and more, while GTA focused all their energy on making a better driving simulator. I don't care for for all the inside jokes and all the goofiness in SR - but overall it is a competent sandbox. GTA had a lot of promise after San Andreas. Then the GTA franchise just declined. While GTA IV may be someone's cup of tea, it was a crashing bore as a GTA game.