Putting the 'role' back in role-playing games since 2002.
Donate to Codex
Good Old Games
  • Welcome to rpgcodex.net, a site dedicated to discussing computer based role-playing games in a free and open fashion. We're less strict than other forums, but please refer to the rules.

    "This message is awaiting moderator approval": All new users must pass through our moderation queue before they will be able to post normally. Until your account has "passed" your posts will only be visible to yourself (and moderators) until they are approved. Give us a week to get around to approving / deleting / ignoring your mundane opinion on crap before hassling us about it. Once you have passed the moderation period (think of it as a test), you will be able to post normally, just like all the other retards.

Warhammer Total War: Warhammer III

Joined
Jan 19, 2015
Messages
633
Location
Vindobona
Changed starting positions for Skrag and Kairos are alright at least.
 

tabacila

Augur
Joined
Nov 2, 2011
Messages
326
https://www.totalwar.com/blog/sotg-oct22/

TOTAL WAR: WARHAMMER III – STATE OF THE GAME (OCTOBER ’22)​

TOTAL WAR: WARHAMMER III

CA_oxfordcomma
October 28 2022

twwh3_design_State-of-the-Game-blog-post_1920x1080.jpg

Greetings, Total War: WARHAMMER III fans! Welcome to State of the Game, which is our deep dive into all things Total War.
We’re thrilled to see all the positive comments about Update 2.2, but we know that the beast never rests and lots of you are already rightly excited about what comes next – yes, Update 2.3 is already in the works, and yes, it will be out soon! There’s a little bit more on all of that below, but for now we do hope you enjoy our other offerings in this latest State of the Game.
As always, our dialogue with our players is absolutely vital to the health of the game, and is an absolutely essential element of the Total War Experience. Please do let us know what you think about this blog, the game or anything else Total War via the channels below:
1f4ac.svg
DISCUSS: Total War: WARHAMMER III on Steam
1f4c3.svg
DISCUSS: Total War: WARHAMMER III on the official Forums
1f5e3.svg
CHAT: The Total War Official Discord
Today we talk to our developers about two topics that always seem to get you chatting. Firstly, we catch up with Senior Designer Craig Kirby about the past, present and future of Endgame Scenarios in Total War. We also talk to Lead Campaign Designer Mark Sinclair about WARHAMMER III’s recent issues with Settlement Battles, what’s been done about them and what the future holds.
Let’s get going!
中文版请在我们的B站专栏查看 – https://www.bilibili.com/read/cv19383901

ENDGAME SCENARIOS – PAST, PRESENT & FUTURE​

You’re a lord of war. A master tactician. You’ve led your near endless hordes of troops to glory and you sit proudly on the throne that’s rightfully yours, the bodies of your enemies strewn all around. That’s what Total War is all about, right? To a point, yes, but it’s also about raising the stakes. That’s why as you approach your moment of triumph, all hell breaks loose and joyous success threatens to collapse into bitter defeat.
“We were like, what if we just massively overpower these factions and give them bonuses we would never normally give them and just see what happens?” Senior Designer Craig Kirby says when discussing how the idea for Endgame Scenarios came about. “They are basically just interesting, crazy events inspired by WARHAMMER lore.”
To what extent each scenario is based on existing lore varies. Some are variations on existing story themes, such as the Wood Elf event (which is based on the Wild Hunt). However, others are chosen for no reason other than they’re cool! “The Dwarf’s Scenario is really just making up an excuse for them to go attack their neighbours, because the dwarves don’t really get enough excuse to kick off – it feels like they should be the bad guys, but they never are, right?” Kirby explains. “Games Workshop told us it’s their favourite scenario, so it just goes to show!”
twwh3_design_state_of_the_game_endgames_2_1920x1080-scaled.jpg

WHEN A PLAN COMES TOGETHER
Come a little closer and lean in – we’ve got a secret to tell you. Sometimes, the things that end up being the best part of a video game come about almost by accident. Endgame Scenarios, for example, didn’t even exist until about two weeks before development of Immortal Empires was locked down.
“We realised that we needed something for the endgame,” Kirby states. “We had loads of ideas going back and forth, but it ultimately lots of people were busy on all the other stuff they had to focus on. I was brought onto the team to help ship Immortal Empires and I was like ‘look, I’ll take it – I don’t mind going a bit crazy’. I think it might have been the last feature we added to Immortal Empires.”
Beyond the Dwarves and Update 2.2’s Skaven (more on that below!) there are several possibilities as to where the developers will turn for their next Endgame Scenario – and it’s safe to say they’re not short of options, with a long list of scenario ideas having already been approved by Games Workshop.
“So here’s one I really like: We hear a lot about the Lizardmen’s ‘great plan’, but what exactly is it?” Kirby says. “This idea in particular is going to be a lot of fun to make because we can do some wacky stuff, getting the Lizardmen doing things they wouldn’t normally do. We’ve also got this one idea knocking about that basically asks what if Karl Franz becomes the ultimate endgame? What if we have the Empire of Man? Let’s take the traditional good guys and make them the bad guys!
However, Endgame Scenarios have to appeal to players beyond simply relying on their affection for the lore. From a gameplay perspective, their appeal has always focused on the enjoyment of taking the rulebook that would normally govern the game and ripping it up.
twwh3_design_state_of_the_game_endgames_3_1920x1080-scaled.jpg

“As a designer, my favourite thing to do is to create a set of rules and then make something that breaks those rules,” Kirby outlines. If players take any one bit of Endgame Scenarios and ask ‘why did they make that?’ the answer is nearly always going to be ‘because it’s cool and it’s fun, right?’
“We focus in on races that never normally get to fight you, we make them stupidly big, we give them bonuses that they shouldn’t get and we then see if the player can handle it. And the rewards are potentially huge. Beat up the faction leader? Then why not confederate them? Now all those OP armies they’ve just been smacking you over the head with are yours!”
VERMINTIDE
Update 2.2 brought with it a brand new Endgame Scenario that will be very recognisable to WARHAMMER fans – the rodentia-themed Vermintide! And the developers were very keen to ensure that dedicated players faced every bit the same challenge as everyone else.
We’ve noticed that most high-level players like to trigger the Endgame Scenario early, which means in the case of Vermintide that the Skaven have bad tech and their buildings will suck,” Kirby says. “So we were just like ‘OK, when the Endgame starts, let’s max out Skaven’s tech!’.”
Of course, even those who aren’t as hot with their WARHAMMER knowledge may well recognise the ‘Vermintide’ moniker thanks to Fatshark’s popular first person online game series of the same name – which, incidentally, has plenty of admirers among the Total War development team.
“We really like their game, and hopefully they like ours!” Kirby adds. “Fans of the Fatshark games should definitely keep their eyes peeled for an Easter Egg or two…”
twwh3_design_state_of_the_game_vermintide_2_1920x1080-scaled.jpg

Of course, rules exist for a reason, and in game development it’s often incredibly important to stick to the rules that are understood by the player. Because of this, the whole concept of Endgame Scenarios poses a risk that has to be mitigated – and this is achieved through the system’s in-built customisation options.
“Customisation is absolutely key,” Kirby adds. “Whenever you’re doing something which is wacky and outside the normal sandbox rules, you should give the player the option to tailor it, even if that means turning it off.”
The team was also acutely aware of the danger Endgame Scenarios present. While a challenging curveball delights a lot of players, the developers were also very aware that some commanders who had toiled over a campaign for dozens of hours or more may not appreciate the possibility of everything falling apart at the last. That’s why customisation was a hugely important part of the feature’s development.
I always say that if we release a piece of content and someone loves 80% of it but hates 20% of it, then ultimately what we’ve achieved is to release a piece of content that they hate,” Kirby says. “Give them the ability to customise it, however, and it can become something they love, and with almost no extra work.
“We know that it’s quite a Marmite feature – some people love it, some people hate it, and that’s where the idea of customisation came from. And we’ll be adding more customisation options in upcoming patches, too.”
twwh3_design_state_of_the_game_endgames_1_1920x1080-scaled.jpg

LOVE TO THE MODDERS
The creativity of modders brings so much to the world of Total War. It’s for that reasons that, from the off, developers ensured that Endgame Scenarios were built in such a way as to allow modders to easily add their own Scenarios.
This dynamic design was also the reasons why the next big addition to Endgame Scenario functionality took a little longer to arrive than we might have liked. Check out the ‘Looking Ahead’ section below for more…
As well as working to ensure that Endgame Scenarios remain customisable and something that works for all players, the developers are also adamant that they will remain accessible to all players, too.
“I’ve seen people speculate that, for example, we’d not yet made a Skaven Endgame Scenario because we were holding it back for an appropriate piece of DLC, but that has never been the plan for any of this content,” Kirby outlines. “These are meant to be a feature for all players.
“The philosophy for us has always been clear – even if you don’t own a DLC, you can still encounter that faction in the map and you can still fight against them. Endgames, in particular, are a doubling down on that idea, and the hope is that eventually, at some point, every single faction in the game will be represented in some kind of Endgame or Endgame-like scenario. We want to show off the cool stuff we have!”

SETTLEMENT BATTLES – UNSETTLING THE BALANCE​

We’re all aware that Settlements had become a bit of a sticky issue in WARHAMMER III. Update 2.2 strove to address the situation by reducing the frequency with which players will encounter Settlement battles. Whether it went far enough will ultimately be for players to decide.
We spoke with Lead Campaign Designer Mark Sinclair about Settlement Battles in WARHAMMER III, and what the future has in store.
Walled-Settlement-Battle-01.png

SO, WHAT ARE THE ISSUES PLAYERS HAVE FACED WITH SETTLEMENT BATTLES?​

MARK SINCLAIR: WARHAMMER III has two different types of Settlement Battles – Minor, which are unwalled and unfortified, and Walled, which are the big siege battles. There are a lot of Settlements on the Immortal Empires map and they’re quite densely packed, especially in the Empire area.
What this meant for players was that the majority of their battles could end up being Minor Settlements, and they weren’t getting as many land battles as they would have liked. Our design was less of an issue in Realms of Chaos because the Settlements were more spaced out.

WAS THE ISSUE NOT PICKED UP DURING DEVELOPMENT?​

MS: To be honest it’s something we thought could happen, and we had planned to address it sooner. Ultimately, uncertainty combined with us not wanting to second guess how players might feel about it. Plus, as Immortal Empires was launching in Beta, we knew there would be lots of scope for gauging reaction and making changes accordingly.
Field-Battle.png

WHAT CHANGES WERE INTRODUCED IN UPDATE 2.2?​

MS: The default now is that when players fight over a Minor Settlement, it will now take the form of a regular, open land battle, where you’re outmanoeuvring the enemy and not worrying about penetrating city defences. This should swing the balance back more towards the land battles.
To get a Minor Settlement battle now, players have to upgrade their city in a specific way via a Garrison upgrade. The option isn’t found in every city, so the ratio of land battles to Minor Settlement battles is going to be a lot better. I think players will have a better experience with it now.

WILL THIS WHOLE EXPERIENCE SHAPE HOW THE TEAM APPROACHES SETTLEMENT BATTLES IN THE FUTURE?​

MS: It’s definitely been a learning experience. The Settlement design was new to WARHAMMER III and we of course wanted to promote it and get it in the hands of players, but we can now see that we pushed too far too quickly. In the future we need to potentially be a bit more careful with new designs and think very hard before putting it front and centre and risking upsetting the existing balance – after all, we never want to take something people love away from them.
Land battles are the standard, the bread and butter, the thing people are familiar with – in retrospect it should not have been a surprise to us that players were so attached to them.
Walled-Settlement-Battle-02.png

SETTLEMENTS POST UPDATE 2.2
In the wake of the changes made in Update 2.2, we’re aware that some players felt the changes made to Settlements went too far. We’re also aware that other players are largely happy with the update, so we’re in the process of evaluating everything people have told us and deciding on the next steps.
The Settlement changes have also raised some other issues:

GARRISONS​

We’re aware that there’s a general feeling among some players that garrisons are uniformly weak across the board, and that this problem has only become more pronounced since walls were removed from so many sieges. We’re in the process of looking again at garrison effectiveness, and will let you all know if changes are decided upon.

BRETONNIA​

Players have pointed out that the Settlement changes have a more notable impact on Bretonnia as they are reliant on tier upgrades for Settlement walls. In addition, Bretonnia already has the weakest garrisons in the game. This double-hit of factors has left the faction feeling weaker than it was before, although it’s also true to say that this is thematically fitting, such is their tendency to veer away from technology and lean heavily into the use of destitute peasants. We’re looking at all this very hard right now to try and find the right balance.


LOOKING FORWARD​


With Update 2.2 now in the hands of players, our attention turns to what’s next. The truth is that while we’re close, we’re still in the process of finalising the whats and whens of WARHAMMER III’s next few months, and we’re going to delve deeper into the specifics of all that in our next State of the Game, which we will have with you before the end of the year. So not long to wait!
Until then, however, here’s a very brief overview of what to expect:

UPDATE 2.3​

WARHAMMER III’s next update approaches rapidly, with our developers currently finalising things as you read these very words. 2.3’s going to be in your hands in the near future, and will be the game’s final patch of 2022. Expect some housekeeping in the wake of 2.2, and while it won’t be as huge as that update, it’s growing all the time and you can still look forward to lots of tweaks and improvements.

MULTIPLAYER ENDGAME SCENARIOS​

You asked for it, now you’re getting it. The multiplayer iteration of Endgame Scenarios is being re-jigged to get all the same functionality as the single player version! And the even better news is that development is very nearly done, meaning it should be in your hands pretty soon!

2023​

Yep, it’s very nearly that time of year once again. There’s Christmas ads everywhere, those weird neighbours at the end of the street have already got the inflatable snowman and Father Christmas up in the front garden, and we still have no idea what to buy mum this year.
In terms of WARHAMMER III, Update 3.0 will most likely be dropping some time in Q2 2023, as will Regiments of Renown IV. We’re also evaluating the possibility of an additional update before then, although nothing’s set in stone.
We’ll have more info on all of this next time out.

CPU & GPU ADVICE​

We also wanted to slip in a quick note regarding CPU and GPU temperatures. We’ve received a few isolated reports of users experiencing some excessive heat when playing WARHAMMER III. Should this effect you in any way, then please do reach out to SEGA Support at the link below.

Lol. What a fucking joke. Another patch next month, but any real new content for WH3 will 'likely' come in Q2 2023. That's April-June 2023. This is even a bigger content drought than the first years of WH2. Apparently having 2 teams work on WH3 at the same time makes CA suck even more at delivering content.
 

InD_ImaginE

Arcane
Patron
Joined
Aug 23, 2015
Messages
6,106
Pathfinder: Wrath
Hey they need to wait some modders to finish something bug to take idea from allright? Please understand
 

tabacila

Augur
Joined
Nov 2, 2011
Messages
326
To be fair, they actually said they may be this shit 6 months ago when they showed their roadmap:
2022-Roadmap-1920x1080-1.jpg


But going from maybe Q4 2022 to Q2 2023 for 3.0 (i.e. real new content) is kinda amazing. Maybe they're about to get rid of some talented and rapey people?
9si0hqc6qxv91.jpg
 

Fedora Master

STOP POSTING
Patron
Edgy
Joined
Jun 28, 2017
Messages
32,562
Im playing as Belegar and it's actually pretty fun now. There is A LOT to do around you, so going after the Karak is not easy.
 

AdamReith

Arcane
Patron
Joined
Oct 21, 2019
Messages
2,116
Enjoy the Revolution! Another revolution around the sun that is.
Legend thinks WH3 has very few people left working on it https://www.youtube.com/clip/UgkxAFZjwLtTdhWRRYNmIGUher-jhjZgGLBX

Seems like '2 teams' for WH3 means the same thing 'different teams' meant for WH2 before 3K launched: skeleton crew on WH while most of the devs are working on the next big release. Also probably half of the people on these 2 teams are busy making inane blog and social media post.
And the other half are clearly sexually assaulting the shit out of them while they do it.

Creative Assembly still hard at it.
 

Lacrymas

Arcane
Joined
Sep 23, 2015
Messages
18,916
Pathfinder: Wrath
They really should fix the content that already exists before slapping on other extraneous vestiges.
 

Mitleser2020

Scholar
Joined
Aug 6, 2020
Messages
1,729
Publisher news
Total War: WARHAMMER III”, the new title in the previous fiscal year was strong at the beginning, it was not as good as expected thereafter, so we worried about it," the publisher explained in an investors call from late October.

"However, due to the implementation of large-scale updates, it is showing a major recovery, and we expect it to catch up in the future."

Total War: Warhammer 3 has received several updates focusing on balance and bug fixing, but, in the presentation, the publisher singles out the game's August update – which introduced the Immortal Empires integrated beta – as a turning point for the grand strategy game.

"Total War: WARHAMMER III" recorded a high Metacritic score and performed well immediately after its launch in February, but since then, sales have been below expectations. However, we were able to improve the points raised by users in the major update in August, as well as other issues, and once again regain the high evaluation."
While updates have played a role in the game's recovery, Sega also expects the inevitable DLC that will follow to contribute to sales.

"As a synergistic effect, sales of DLCs released in the past have also been strong, and we expect this to contribute to the accumulation of repeat sales in the future."
https://www.gamewatcher.com/news/se...war-warhammer-3-post-launch-sales-performance
 

Fedora Master

STOP POSTING
Patron
Edgy
Joined
Jun 28, 2017
Messages
32,562
They shat out one of the worst campaigns in the history of the company and the game was rated lower than Rome 2 at launch.
 

Lacrymas

Arcane
Joined
Sep 23, 2015
Messages
18,916
Pathfinder: Wrath
The game lacks depth and the skill ceiling is very low imo, it needs much more than fixed sieges and a big map.
 

Cyberarmy

Love fool
Patron
Joined
Feb 7, 2013
Messages
8,705
Location
Smyrna - Scalanouva
Divinity: Original Sin 2
Yeah, crude humor :)
  • Customisable Endgame Scenarios make their way to multiplayer.
  • The eight original WARHAMMER I Lords receive brand-new selection videos.
  • Landmarks from Mortal Empires and the Realm of Chaos maps arrive in Immortal Empires, along with some new landmarks and 10-slot settlements for select factions.
  • Further tweaks to the victory objectives of several Legendary Lords including Kislev, Tomb Kings and the Ogre Kingdoms.
  • A sweep of balance changes to Tomb Kings, Vampire Counts, Skaven and more.
  • Changes to how the AI dodges spells, artillery and other ranged attacks, along with new difficulty adjustments.
https://www.totalwar.com/blog/tww3-update-230/
 

_V_

Liturgist
Joined
Jun 15, 2015
Messages
116
Less morale/faster crumbling for undead? Who asked for that? Why exacerbate a shitty "feature"?
The rest sounds good. I'd like an option for more crafty AI on higher battle difficulties without the enemy buffs they worked with so far.
 

Mitleser2020

Scholar
Joined
Aug 6, 2020
Messages
1,729
Less morale/faster crumbling for undead? Who asked for that?

The multiplayer guys? I heard that undead factions do better in Domination mode than others thanks to their units not running away or quickly crumbling like demons.
 
Joined
Jan 7, 2012
Messages
15,484
Crumbling barely matters in campaign, your shit chaff units you can just raise from the dead after battle. Everything else doesn't crumble unless its getting its shit kicked in badly + you have some of the best healing in the game.
 

kris

Arcane
Joined
Oct 27, 2004
Messages
8,896
Location
Lulea, Sweden
i would say crumbling dont matter so much for players playing undead, but they will be much easier to defeat now. Snipe the lord tactics to work again?
 

As an Amazon Associate, rpgcodex.net earns from qualifying purchases.
Back
Top Bottom