I agree Stone Tower is great, but outside of that I pretty strongly disagree.
Nah they're all pretty good
The forest dungeon alone is possibly the best "woodland" themed dungeon of the series
I straight-up hate City in the Sky and would consider it the worst dungeon in the game after Temple of Time
City in the Sky was good, one of the best dungeons in TP
If nothing else, the art and atmosphere was pretty unique:
While TP was a derivative game, it can't be said it wasn't memorable
It had a significant amount of cool ideas and moments - plus the dungeons were fine
Water Temple from OoT ... MM
Now that I think about it, I just realised TP's Water Temple was mix and matching of both those dungeons
Like TP's it was a tower shaped dungeon whose goal lies at the bottom, but like MM the primary gimmick was the control of the water flow
Also Link's movement underwater, was done both by using the iron boots to sink to the pool's floor and using a magick costume that allowed Link to swim with greater finesse
I just want to have a fairly easy-going time and occasionally think “oh that’s a clever bit of puzzle/level/art design”.
I am completely disagree with this though
To clarify, I don't want these games to be Zelda II hard - although I welcome and appreciate BotW early to mid game "lethality"
I just want to them to keep me enganged - to make use my head, you know
Something which doesn't happen when they play like you've just described
Because you've essentially just described Wind Waker (among many other weaker Zelda titles) - and I absolutely fucking hate WW
And while I agree that when these games are like this they're not bad, but they're also not good - what they are is utterly mediocre, bland, generic, predictable, safe and just too easy
OoT, MM, TP - despite having not played these games in many years, I still remeber bits from every dungeon, I still remember times whan I was excited, frusted and even enlightened (as in finally figuring out the answer)
On other hand, despite playing WW at the heigh of my enthusiasm for the series during my late childhood/early teens, I barely remember jack shit about it
In fact what I most remember is general boredom and ultimately a disappointment that would sour me on these games until BotW