Most suffer from a weird difference between the ending itself and the vid calls during the credits that do not really match it.
The Arasaka ending aka "lol didn't do any sidequests lol they are not essential lol" is just depressing as fuck. Like spending 30 mins watching a terminal cancer patient being pushed in a wheelchair towards his execution. Slavs sure love their depressiv shit. Not gonna lie, I got slightly wet eyes. From a fly that got in of course.
Vid calls when you go back to earth don't match that decision, but whatevs.
The Avocado ending is, at it is now, the only "good" ending taking vid calls in account. But getting there is... stupid. The faction known for smuggling, stealth and ambushes decide to charge headlong into the fray in their Lada Nivas. Instead of riding in the tank, which Mitch tells you is actually and APC. Sure, why not.
That whole ride is just to give the consoletards their awsome action where you press buttons and awsome things happen. None of the named death had any impact on me, the moment the new guys were introduced I knew they would kick the bucket. And after Mitch badmouthed Saul, the only question was: do I have to shoot him or will he die somewhat "heroically"?
Then of course the tacked on "6 month left" crap. As if the Avocados would find a solution somewhere in the desert... At least the vidcalls were happy.
The Johnny ending: since V practially begged Johnny to take the body I expected a "V becomes a rockstar" ending. Fuck no. Johnny slacks away in some shitty apartment, has no money, no car, and runs away like a pussy. Not even having the balls to call V's friends and say goodbye. After watching Judy cry for minutes I expect her to go out like Evelyn as well. Fuck you Johnny.
Panam said all that needs to be said in her temper tantrum.
The "Space" ending was the best IMHO. At first I thought V wanted to go out with a bang, but Mr Blue Eyes says "you woudl do anything for a chance to live"... Considering that he is an
alien AI I assume he can indeed heal V. AltF4 Cunningham knew shit about human bodies, so she lacked the ability to do so, but those AIs live among the humans and have shown in the Perelez quest they know how to manipulate the human body.
The Rogue role in it was... okay I guess. I knew she would go out with a bang the moment she switched of the lights in Afterlife. She had an unhealthy obsession with him and was apparently fed up with the quiet life.
Best ending is of course the secret one followed by the above. You get the cake AND Rogue lives. Best deal.
Except Judy ditched V. WTF, she just said she would wait for her 5 mins ago.
And Takemura's call of course. Sad.