The least autistic PoE player gives his perspective. He is usually a pretty positive guy and tries to do a measured and balanced take:
tl;dw:
- visuals are great
- UI is bad
- sound balancing is sometimes off, some of the soundtrack can get very annoying after a while
- game is heavily instanced and you'll see about a dozen players at most
- you can't opt out of the online
- other players ruin the immersion
- world is very Lost Ark-y, large open areas without any monsters
- world events are mostly about killing some monsters attacking carts, but sometimes you get a more interesting one
- dungeons are important to progression, as you unlock crafting recipes and quests there
- some dungeons feature the "kill all monsters in the zone" task which can get very annoying
- a lot of backtracking
- a lot of repetition in the layouts and bosses
- rumor has it that these dungeons are what you'll be running in the endgame (lmao if true)
- rest of zone completions tasks are standard boring AssCreed/MMO fare
- zone completion gives out very important rewards, so it will feel like a chore
- you have to collect herbs in order to craft xp buff elixirs
- world boss spawned approx 4 times during the weekend and is on a set schedule (fuck you, people with jobs/friends/life)
- world boss is aids for melee
- world boss can easily one-shot you, but his attacks are telegraphed
- looks spectacular but mechanically very simple
- world boss just despawns if your instance can't kill him in time (lul)
- rogue class is very bland, all skills feel the same, ultimates are very disappointing
- rogues use the dynamic melee/ranged system which lets you equip two sets of weapons and your character will use the appropriate one, he likes the system a lot
- skill tree is very simple and the customization options are very limited (only 2 per any given skill vs the 5 from D3)
- rumor has it that the Paragon system will enable much greater customization (COPIUMTRUCK)
- gear was very boring up until lvl 23-25 where the affixes started getting more interesting, maybe an upwards trend (COPIUMSHIPMENT)
- gear customization system is good and shines in comparison to other MMO-style games and within D4 itself (but nothing amazing compared to ARPG standards)
- his bottom line: it's Diablo Immortal + Lost Ark that you have to pay 100bux for