- Joined
- Jan 4, 2005
- Messages
- 24,793
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c4bcb/c4bcb0752d25a4f5219ab5e4e5786dd54670c279" alt="Insert Title Here Insert Title Here"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ff9c2/ff9c2b2148ca44c0d16f260997b18af4b80cbbe7" alt="RPG Wokedex RPG Wokedex"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/827f4/827f469d6c6241e8dd5f5c243cba2ef0ea43cde2" alt="Codex Year of the Donut Codex Year of the Donut"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/48602/48602d5b4102d82770f6f1512a43d6c28298cd5c" alt="I'm very into cock and ball torture I'm very into cock and ball torture"
Yeah but first time through you probably won't focus on combat 100%. But you should.
Finished game!
Ending is... eh.
I like the plot though, old-fashioned and iffy as it was. I'd happily play the sequel. I think the hook is good and it'd be nice to see.
The final battle... well, for all my shitting on 2-handed weapons, I /did/ beat the final boss in two full 2-handed combos. I did buff up first, though. Still, that's... pretty damn good.
I played the entire game, start to finish, on Ultra, and picked mostly combat and survival talents with a dash of buffing spells.
I got the 'cold' ending - which seems like the 'good' ending to me, though I haven't seen the others. But it certainly made sense. Somewhat.
In the end my happiness to play a new Gothic game made me overlook some serious flaws with this game.
However, flawed as it is, this is a big greater than the sum of its part kind of deal and I would not hesitate to rate the game 7-8 out of 10 (on a Jasede scale, where even a 5 is still decent).
The things that hold it back are the same as every PB game: bugs, combat could be smoother, writing could use some work. However, world-building and exploration are Gothic-tier, even if the atmosphere isn't.
I felt very happy to have paid full price for this.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e3162/e316292608def339238a5ed6f2f91b2e336392f9" alt="Salute :salute: :salute:"
Finished game!
Ending is... eh.
I like the plot though, old-fashioned and iffy as it was. I'd happily play the sequel. I think the hook is good and it'd be nice to see.
The final battle... well, for all my shitting on 2-handed weapons, I /did/ beat the final boss in two full 2-handed combos. I did buff up first, though. Still, that's... pretty damn good.
I played the entire game, start to finish, on Ultra, and picked mostly combat and survival talents with a dash of buffing spells.
I got the 'cold' ending - which seems like the 'good' ending to me, though I haven't seen the others. But it certainly made sense. Somewhat.
In the end my happiness to play a new Gothic game made me overlook some serious flaws with this game.
However, flawed as it is, this is a big greater than the sum of its part kind of deal and I would not hesitate to rate the game 7-8 out of 10 (on a Jasede scale, where even a 5 is still decent).
The things that hold it back are the same as every PB game: bugs, combat could be smoother, writing could use some work. However, world-building and exploration are Gothic-tier, even if the atmosphere isn't.
I felt very happy to have paid full price for this.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e3162/e316292608def339238a5ed6f2f91b2e336392f9" alt="Salute :salute: :salute:"