Larian cultists reviewing BG1/2 - NOW with IWD:EE reviews

[rusty_shackleford]

I wouldn't call it OP then, rather a limitation of the time that has been rectified in many games that came after the Baldur's Gate series.

There's zero good isometric RPGs that came after the IE games. "Rectified". You're probably one of the authors of these reviews. Enjoy the rectifications from Larian.

reminder that this poster hates D: OS because he's terrible at it

I wish I had your outlook on things, then everything would be so easy. But every battle in Divos takes half an hour. What a snooze fest. It's to the point where you dread the next battle.

However bad POE's fights were, at least I always felt in control. In Divos you just watch things unfold and can't do anything for a long while. And when they CC your characters on top of it, oh boy. What would've been over in a matter of minutes with RTWP, takes half an hour in TB.

 

[Gargaune]

No usernames? How am I supposed to update my .txt?

 

[Orud]

"The myth of consensual gameplay. He agrees, she agrees, tabletop disagrees." Who cares.

Hand over your 3.x, Pathfinder and Troika toys, right now.

 

[Nano]

Gameplay should be king. And it is in BG.

Gameplay would still be king if they properly adapted the PnP rules. Difference being that the gameplay would've been less retarded.

 

[Russia is over. The end.]

Gameplay should be king. And it is in BG.

Gameplay would still be king if they properly adapted the PnP rules. Difference being that the gameplay would've been less retarded.

So you're a BG hater. You should've prefaced your messages with that disclaimer, it means there's nothing to discuss with you.

 

[polo]

Truth to be told it really is annoying that there is no AoE range indicator in IE games.

I disagree. If you know the exact area of a fireball, you can abuse it too much, e.g. tank all enemies just centimeters away from damage, but let all the enemies take it. That's too contrived and OP. The entire idea of uncertainty and precautions when launching a fireball makes it like playing with fire. Great, that's exactly how it's intended.

i actually thought for a time some spells should have some kind of random AOE to make it even more interesting.

 

[Jigby]

Truth to be told it really is annoying that there is no AoE range indicator in IE games.

I disagree. If you know the exact area of a fireball, you can abuse it too much, e.g. tank all enemies just centimeters away from damage, but let all the enemies take it. That's too contrived and OP. The entire idea of uncertainty and precautions when launching a fireball makes it like playing with fire. Great, that's exactly how it's intended.

Indeed, perfect information games are boring. Change my mind.
exception being chess/go

 

[rusty_shackleford]

Truth to be told it really is annoying that there is no AoE range indicator in IE games.

I disagree. If you know the exact area of a fireball, you can abuse it too much, e.g. tank all enemies just centimeters away from damage, but let all the enemies take it. That's too contrived and OP. The entire idea of uncertainty and precautions when launching a fireball makes it like playing with fire. Great, that's exactly how it's intended.

Indeed, perfect information games are boring. Change my mind.

I agree, every mage should be a wild mage and the location of targeted spells should be completely random.

 

[Jigby]

Truth to be told it really is annoying that there is no AoE range indicator in IE games.

I disagree. If you know the exact area of a fireball, you can abuse it too much, e.g. tank all enemies just centimeters away from damage, but let all the enemies take it. That's too contrived and OP. The entire idea of uncertainty and precautions when launching a fireball makes it like playing with fire. Great, that's exactly how it's intended.

Indeed, perfect information games are boring. Change my mind.

I agree, every mage should be a wild mage and the location of targeted spells should be completely random.

Clearly you hate probabilistic games

 

[Orud]

I agree, every mage should be a wild mage and the location of targeted spells should be completely random.

i actually thought for a time some spells should have some kind of random AOE to make it even more interesting.

Meredoth's turning around in his grave.

 

[Cryomancer]

It has to be impossible for someone to be that retarded.

Human ignorance is limitless. Mainly for modern gamers an game journos

G3 negative reviews simply because BG3 isn't RTwP is worse than any of these btw

No, being RtWP or TB is irrelevant. Dark Sun : Wake of the Ravager is a masterpiece and it is TB.

Meredoth's turning around in his grave.

No, the idea of making magic more risky is always interesting. IMO if you are casting a fireball, took a attack of opportunity, you should get a CON check. If failed, it should blow up in your own hands.

 

[rusty_shackleford]

Truth to be told it really is annoying that there is no AoE range indicator in IE games.

I disagree. If you know the exact area of a fireball, you can abuse it too much, e.g. tank all enemies just centimeters away from damage, but let all the enemies take it. That's too contrived and OP. The entire idea of uncertainty and precautions when launching a fireball makes it like playing with fire. Great, that's exactly how it's intended.

Indeed, perfect information games are boring. Change my mind.

I agree, every mage should be a wild mage and the location of targeted spells should be completely random.

Clearly you hate probabilistic games

No, I just think a mage should know the radius of their spells if they're capable of memorizing and casting them.
If I were implementing it, I'd make each spell have its own related hidden skill for targeting that developed over time & when using it that gradually became more accurate in position/radius representing the mage's expertise with the spell.

But I did not design D&D, therefore if I were implementing D&D, I'd defer to their ruleset.

 

[Cryomancer]

because he's terrible at it

His critique seems to be against TB system, not cuz he is bad.

What would've been over in a matter of minutes with RTWP, takes half an hour in TB.

His critique is fine. However, the greatest problem of DOS2 is not the TB system. Is the TB system with ultra slow animations and low lethality. See how combat is fast in this TB game



Here is another game. In less than 30 seconds, he ended the first encounter

 

[Fedora Master]

I've never had issues with spell aoe after using them a few times. You quickly develop a feeling for their range. Besides, Fireball isn't something you throw around willy-nilly, you use it to open combat with. If you want safe in-combat aoe spells, Horrid Wilting is king.

 

[Nano]

I've never had issues with spell aoe after using them a few times. You quickly develop a feeling for their range. Besides, Fireball isn't something you throw around willy-nilly, you use it to open combat with. If you want safe in-combat aoe spells, Horrid Wilting is king.

Horrid Wilting is not a party-friendly spell in PnP. Which is much less of a problem when you have AoE indicators.

 

[Fedora Master]

I've never had issues with spell aoe after using them a few times. You quickly develop a feeling for their range. Besides, Fireball isn't something you throw around willy-nilly, you use it to open combat with. If you want safe in-combat aoe spells, Horrid Wilting is king.

Horrid Wilting is not a party-friendly spell in PnP. Which is much less of a problem when you have AoE indicators.

Chain Lightning then. Point is: In the IE games there are party friendly aoe spells.

Besides, mages are not blasters anyway.

 

[Lacrymas]

All of these reviews just indicate these players were filtered hard.

 

[Fedora Master]

All of these reviews just indicate these players were filtered hard.

Imagine these reviewers encountering Kangaxx.

 

[Tyranicon]

That 46 hours review is definitely trolling. It has to be impossible for someone to be that retarded.

I thought so too, but Steam is full of mouth breathers.

 

[Szenhidrat]

I, for one, welcome our new larian overlords. It was time people start to shit on those ugly graphics. I mean... drawings(lol) and paintings(LUL)?? It's not the 13th century anymore.

 

[Zeriel]

The decline is constant and sharp, and I do not hope for a better world for anyone. In fact, I want my pain to be inflicted on others. I want no one to escape. But even after admitting this, there is no catharsis; my punishment continues to elude me, and I gain no deeper knowledge of myself. No new knowledge can be extracted from my telling. This confession has meant nothing.

 

[Humbaba]

46 hours in the Irenicus Dungeon good lord. There's no way these reviewers were above the age of 15.

 

[Deuce Traveler]

The original D&D fireball spell was calculated in volume rather than by radius. They changed it since calculating the volume while inside a dungeon was too complicated, but I'd enjoy seeing a game implement it just so you could see the negative reviews from people throwing a fireball down a narrow corridor for the very first time.

 

[NJClaw]

46 hours in the Irenicus Dungeon good lord. There's no way these reviewers were above the age of 15.

15?

I was 8 when I finished Baldur's Gate 2. And I think my post history here on the Codex can back me up when I say that I'm not the brightest guy around. You just need a basic understanding of how colors and shapes work to determine that buttons with red flames hurt your enemies and buttons with blue shields protect your allies.

Anyway, there's no way that "46 hours" review isn't satire. Too dumb to be real.

 

[Serus]

I've never had issues with spell aoe after using them a few times. You quickly develop a feeling for their range. Besides, Fireball isn't something you throw around willy-nilly, you use it to open combat with. If you want safe in-combat aoe spells, Horrid Wilting is king.

The thing is, after a few hours of playing BG2 with a fireball or two being memorised you know almost perfectly what the range is anyway. For this reason there is no point in hiding it. It isn't a gameplay change only a quality of life one.

Also BG1 (as in the first one) sucked and there are many crpgs made after it that are better. Though perhaps not BG3, i can't know.