No way man. BG1 had some incredible innovation at the time and a really tight narrative that most games (whether they know it or not) owe a lot to. Also, Real Time with Pause (RTwP) will probably go down in history as the innovation the *saved* RPGs.In fact, I honestly think Baldur's Gate is the worst of the IE games.
The people that don't like RTwP are probably the same folks who are going back and playing Fallout 2 and saying to themselves "Wow, this game is great, but it would be AMAZING if I could run around like in Diablo and shoot things." I'm not saying RTwP is best everywhere, but it sure as hell works everywhere its used: BG1, Ultima VII, Arcanum. You name it!