Quit Evil Islands as I just got tired of learning maps by reloading. Just finished
Mafia II two days ago. Took about 13 hours according to Steam, but it wasn't too bad. If you like cutscenes, driving across maps, annoying fistfight mechanics, and shooting small armies, this is the game for you. If you like open worlds... not so much.
World design: excellent. Huge detailed map of 1951
Missions: very good. The missions followed the story, and it was mixed up quite a bit. However, most missions were go to this point - cutscene - drive to this point - cutscene - shoot guys. Repeat shoot guys if you fail.
World itself: Very, very little to do other than outrun the cops and drive to checkpoints. In fact, there just was nothing outside the missions worth doing. Getting a fast car upgraded, filling the gas tank and getting a car wash were there, but didn't really have any bearing on the game. You could buy a change of clothes, but there about 4 different outfits and thats it. You could eat, but it really didn't affect anything other than a useless bump in health.
Music: Excellent! Best music I've ever had in a sandbox game, other than Vice City. Can't really get sick of it, as the game is only 13 freaking hours. Don't even think I heard all of it. Nice to hear
Buddy Holly ("Rave On") while driving around. Yes, the game year was 1951, and Rave On was released in 1958, but I'm not complaining. None of the damn songs were the right year, come to think of it...
Gunfights: not bad. A burst from enemies can kill you, as well as a well aimed shot or two. However, you regen when not shot, fairly fast. It's a mixed bag.
Story: pretty good.
Got this and the DLC on Steam for $11 total. Worth it, but don't expect more than a sequential move through a linear story. It's a good story, though. A HUGE waste of a really good map, though. As an explorefag, cities you'd like to look around in but there isn't anything worth seeing, so no reason to run through the streets. A pity.