Yep, and that's why I think they should be giving 3 points per level instead of 1 or 2.
I disagree with this.
Keep the skill point gain per level the same, but remove the pre-requisite ability. Instead change it pre-requisite level. Meaning some is only accessible at Lvl 1, 3, 5, 7, 9 so on. And yes, you can save ability points. It should be more interesting what kind of build people can come up with that flexibility.
Also, forgot not playing Ironman anymore, quit without saving. Blyat.
Anyway, let's do a bad distinction review. Because they really need balancing IMO.
The Bad ones:
Cannibal
+ 15 Survival
+ Gains 3 x meat off human kills
- 2 Personality
Review: This is a very mediocre perk even if you dump Personality. The +15 Survival isn't gonna help much in early game and it doesn't really give you much use elsewhere. The developer really neglected this skill in dialogue checks. The meat DOES give you additional resource for healing/experience when consumed or money when sold.
Recommended fix: Lose the Survival bonus replace it with +10% damage to humanoids.
Now that's something that catches the eye of a character builder.
Sex Appeal
+/- 2 Personality based on Gender
+/- 15 Barter based on Gender
Review: Absolute garbage.
Recommended fix: Switch the name to Misogynist (Man) or Misandrist (Woman).
Double the Penalty and bonus
Add speech craft bonus & penalty on top of it
Then increase and decrease damage based on gender by 10%
Then post this on social media for publicity
Child prodigy
+ 1 Intellect
+ 1 Personality
+ 1 Attention
- 50% EXP gains
Review: Horrible. Really gimps your character advancement. Probably the worst of the lot.
Recommended fix: The bonus / penalty doesn't remind me of a prodigy. More like of a stubborn learner who wants to stick to his own ways and does not listen to others.
Rename this to Stubborn Learner, give the character more intellect but penalize his personality. Lower his EXP penalty because 50% loss is too massive for the minor benefit it brings.
Change name to 'Stubborn Learner'
+ 3 Intellect
- 2 Personality
- 20% EXP gains
Ascetic
+ Twice the time to get hungry
+ 10 Survival
- 1 Strength
- 7 kg Carry weight
Review: What a bare bone perk. I can't see any value at all in picking this.
Savage Hunter
+ 20% damage vs Animals
+ Skins without knife
- 2 Personality
- 15 kg Carry weight
Review: The bonus is very small. Unless you're fighting Alpha wolf pack at low level, you won't feel much benefit, especially after you've unlocked the Witcher Ability by mid game. So you lose 15 carry weight, but don't need to carry a 0.5 kg knife in your backpack to skin animals. Yay, very happy for you lah.
Recommended fix:
Add a buff 'Thrill of the Hunt' whenever you kill an animal / mutant, you gain +1 Attention + 4% Critical Chance for 2 hours
Circus Education
+ 1 DEX
+ 15 Sneak
+ 10 Lockpicking & Pickpocketing
- 20 kg Carry weight
- 7 Sequence
Review: No way I'm taking that huge penalty. A net loss of 6 Sequence is too much.
Cursed Sniper
+ 2 Attention
+ 7% Aimed shot chance
- 2 Luck
- 7 Sequence
- 10% Normal shot chance
Review: Nope. It's a net loss of 5 Sequence for small accuracy bonus that doesn't matter once you get to mid game.
Lone Wolf
When alone
+ 2 Attention
+ 5 Sequence
+ 10 kg Carry weight
When with follower
- 2 Attention
- 20 Survival
- 7 Sequence
Review: I don't hate this perk too much cause there's no penalty as long you don't bring any follower. But let's consider the fact you lose around 2 attacks per round, 2 source of damage absorption and additional 100 kg worth of carry weight when traveling alone. It needs to be way better than this.
Recommended Fix:
+ 5 Maximum HP per level up to survive better
+ 30% EXP Gain for faster leveling
Leader
For every follower you get:
+ 7 Speechcraft
+ 5 First Aid
+ 5 Barter
- 1 Attention
- 1 Dexterity
Followers gain
+ 1 Dexterity
+ 1 Endurance
Review:
With this perk, you can't even give command to your followers in the first turn. This is a bad choice if you want to be a leader. With 3 followers, you lose 6 points of attributes. Better to just treat your pals to one sweet roll and onion than taking this perk.