Zero Credibility
Arcane
- Joined
- Feb 11, 2007
- Messages
- 2,952
I think there was more to it then just one line from Alt. She was very blatant about it.
And sure, Rogue could say more about what happened... but is she ever confronted with Johnny's memories? Don't think so. Even if she were, would his ego dominating those events bother her?
Plus the "memory" sections for me kinda prove that whatever happened, was hugely distorted by Johny's overblown ego. I mean look, he's the action hero in these "memories", the others are just his sidekicks that barely matter. He one-shots every enemy, Rogue or Santiago barely put a dent in them. He's leading the charge. The Smasher encounter also went differently in the source material AFAIR.
Well, I don't have the game installed any more, but from what I remember it really was just that one line, and you could miss it completely as well if you don't pick the right option when taking to Alt. Anyway, I went and actually took a brief look at the adventure that this was (supposed to be) based on, and here are my conclusions:
1. This adventure is just bad. There seems to be a ton of railroading, and it feels like PCs end up playing second fiddle to awesome NPCs that actually do shit. And if the PCs dare to interfere in whatever the NPCs are doing - climatic duel, heroic sacrifice, what have you - something prevents them, because "this is not just an adventure, it's a story".
2. The Arasaka tower is actually two twin towers, both to be brought down by a nuke brought in the basement by the second team. Brave freedom fighters bringing down twin towers of evil, why does that feel so familiar? So weird that there only appears to be one tower when we see it in the game, right?
3. On the actual topic at hand, Johnny and his team never had the bomb. It's not clear if he knew about the second team having it at all, but even if he did he had no idea it was intended to destroy the towers, as nobody but the NPC general sending them knew that. Johnny certainly wasn't there to blow up the Arasaka, he was there for Alt.
Now, I can see Johnny embellishing the assault in his memory, sure. I'd expect this to take more than a couple of hours, but why not, it's possible - not a certainty by any means as V can pretty much do whatever Johnny did back then and more - but possible. But why would he imagine bringing, arming and setting off a nuke that he's never even seen? And how the fuck would he completely convince himself that he did all that, to the point that he actually has fake memories of doing so, all in a matter of hours? This just strains credibility to and beyond breaking point. And in the end, if I had to pick between:
1. This unreliable narrator implication is a clever plot twist that sheds completely new light on this story and
2. This unreliable narrator is a half-assed attempt to hide that the story does not actually follow the source material
I'd go with option 2 here, because it's just as half-assed as the rest of this game.