CD Projekt's Cyberpunk 2077 Update 2.0 + Phantom Liberty Expansion Thread

[RRRrrr]

They expected Red Dead Redemption 2 or GTA 5 level sales, yet failed to achieve even The Witcher 3 levels. The game sold well, just not as well as they hoped. After a certain point, simply throwing money at a game is not enough.

 

[Sobchak]

They expected Red Dead Redemption 2 or GTA 5 level sales, yet failed to achieve even The Witcher 3 levels. The game sold well, just not as well as they hoped. After a certain point, simply throwing money at a game is not enough.

It's unfair to compare it with Witcher 3 because it's simply too early. Witcher 3 kept breaking sales records for them even last year. The game will eventually take that route when it's finally what they initially wanted to release.

 

[Tyrr]

They expected Red Dead Redemption 2 or GTA 5 level sales, yet failed to achieve even The Witcher 3 levels. The game sold well, just not as well as they hoped. After a certain point, simply throwing money at a game is not enough.

It's unfair to compare it with Witcher 3 because it's simply too early. Witcher 3 kept breaking sales records for them even last year. The game will eventually take that route when it's finally what they initially wanted to release.

Don't compare sales numbers. Just look at this (from right now):

Which one is the new, and which the 6 year old game?

 

[RRRrrr]

It's unfair to compare it with Witcher 3 because it's simply too early. Witcher 3 kept breaking sales records for them even last year. The game will eventually take that route when it's finally what they initially wanted to release.

I don't see how Cyberpunk could possibly take that route. I know CDP are counting on this, but the game was simply not that well received even in regard to story, C&C and gameplay. The current critical consensus is that even if bugs are fixed, the game will remain mediocre. The critical consensus for The Witcher 3 was the opposite.

 

[Gargaune]

The current critical consensus is that even if bugs are fixed, the game will remain mediocre.

No, that's the Codex Consensus, but Joe McCasual doesn't give a shit about progression systems or level design, he's just pissed off that he can't play taxi driver and that his decade-old PlebStation vomits the disc out. If it weren't for the performance-related problems, the general public would be jerking GOTY awards all over Cyberpunk.

 

[RRRrrr]

If it weren't for the performance-related problems, the general public would be jerking GOTY awards all over Cyberpunk.

Not exactly. In the initial reviews the reviewers were jerking off to CDP so hard their dicks their dicks fell off. But after that, they released new videos bashing the game, including by saying that the main issue is not the bugs, but the underlying game.

So not only is this the Codex consensus, it is also the youtube retard reviewers' consensus.

As for me, I actually really like the gameplay. But the story, despite having some cool moments (I actually like Keanu), is very weak-too much "Corporations baaad hurrr durr I'm 12 and I'm edgyyy" and too little substance. Despite having the opportunity to show a distopian future based extrapolation and current tech (you know, what Deus Ex did), they used an outdated vision of the future and setting simply felt...dated.

And by dated, I mean in a philosophical sense, not in a retro-futurist/80s vision of the future sense. This game simply did not have anything to say about today's world. I might write a separate post about this.

 

[Gargaune]

Not exactly. In the initial reviews the reviewers were jerking off to CDP so hard their dicks their dicks fell off. But after that, they released new videos bashing the game, including by saying that the main issue is not the bugs, but the underlying game.

A very plastic example of how serious "specialist" press is, but the tide only turned once the performance problems on console came to light. After that, clickbait season was open and Cyberpunked was murdering household pets left and right. If the game handled on console as well as it did on PC, none of this would've happened and legitimate design criticism would've been restricted to the likes of the Codex, as usual.

Still, no denying that the board did fuck up by releasing the game prematurely. But it was still extremely successful, and since their contracts are tied to revenue, they get to share in that success.

Yep, money's coming in so the owners are collecting, big whoop. It's just the usual tabloid spin, employee bonuses might be "lower than expected", but who's to say the "$4-6 million" aren't down as well? Are we supposed to be outraged at an even split of funds between the board and the rank-and-file? Yawn.

While we're talking business, can anyone explain distribution on PS5? So Sony booted Cyberpunk from the PS Store, a significant problem for CDPR, but the game's still selling on PS4 via retailers. If someone wants to play the game on PS5, do they just buy a PS4 disc and pop it in, or how does it work?

 

[RRRrrr]

If the game handled on console as well as it did on PC, none of this would've happened and legitimate design criticism would've been restricted to the likes of the Codex, as usual.

Of course. But now that the cat is out of the box and it was open season on all Cyberpunk 2077 flaws, I don't see how the game can pull off a The Witcher 3 consistent post-release sales. It simply doesn't have the reputation TW3 had. Unless CDP pull off another "Enhanced Edition" like with The Witcher 1, they have no chance at critically redeeming the game.

 

[cvv]

They expected Red Dead Redemption 2 or GTA 5 level sales, yet failed to achieve even The Witcher 3 levels.

Dude, just the pre-orders of CP2077 surpassed TW3 two month sales.

 

[Gerrard]

I wonder who gets the biggest bonuses at Bloomberg.

 

[RRRrrr]

Dude, just the pre-orders of CP2077 surpassed TW3 two month sales.

I was referring to all TW3 sales since release, not just the first two months.

 

[cvv]

Dude, just the pre-orders of CP2077 surpassed TW3 two month sales.

I was referring to all TW3 sales since release, not just the first two months.

In that case you're comparing apples to dingleberries.

 

[Tyrr]

I wonder if this will be another DA:O/DA2 situation in the long run.

 

[Gargaune]

Of course. But now that the cat is out of the box and it was open season on all Cyberpunk 2077 flaws, I don't see how the game can pull off a The Witcher 3 consistent post-release sales. It simply doesn't have the reputation TW3 had. Unless CDP pull off another "Enhanced Edition" like with The Witcher 1, they have no chance at critically redeeming the game.

Like cvv pointed out, initial sales were strong, but on the long term it's hard to say, we'll have to see what CDPR pulls in terms of DLC and once adoption of the new console generation is up. I do think CDPR will pivot back to The Witcher series for their next game so they can polish up their brand again.

 

[toro]

Of course. But now that the cat is out of the box and it was open season on all Cyberpunk 2077 flaws, I don't see how the game can pull off a The Witcher 3 consistent post-release sales. It simply doesn't have the reputation TW3 had. Unless CDP pull off another "Enhanced Edition" like with The Witcher 1, they have no chance at critically redeeming the game.

Like cvv pointed out, initial sales were strong, but on the long term it's hard to say, we'll have to see what CDPR pulls in terms of DLC and once adoption of the new console generation is up. I do think CDPR will pivot back to The Witcher series for their next game so they can polish up their brand again.

I don't have the link now but based on their financial report the CP2077 team got reduced therefore they are actively working on something else.

 

[toro]

They expected Red Dead Redemption 2 or GTA 5 level sales, yet failed to achieve even The Witcher 3 levels. The game sold well, just not as well as they hoped. After a certain point, simply throwing money at a game is not enough.

It's unfair to compare it with Witcher 3 because it's simply too early. Witcher 3 kept breaking sales records for them even last year. The game will eventually take that route when it's finally what they initially wanted to release.

Don't compare sales numbers. Just look at this (from right now):

Which one is the new, and which the 6 year old game?

CDPR will never create another game like Witcher 3. CP2077 was their swansong.

 

[Paul_cz]

They expected Red Dead Redemption 2 or GTA 5 level sales, yet failed to achieve even The Witcher 3 levels. The game sold well, just not as well as they hoped. After a certain point, simply throwing money at a game is not enough.

Witcher 3 sold 30 million in 6 year period.

Cyberpunk sold 14 million in 20 days period.

It is mindblowingly idiotic to consider this to be in any way bad. Most games are happy if they reach those 14 million over a decade, and vast majority never does.

With upcoming updates, DLCs, expansions, nextgen ports and netflix show, the sales will continue for years; I bet in 5 years they will be at lot more than 30 million. CDP knows full well it is in their best interest to turn the "internet sentiment" around.

It is fine to dislike the game or whatever, but let's keep some perspective.

 

[RRRrrr]

It is mindblowingly idiotic to consider this to be in any way bad.

Where did I say it was bad you retard. I said "not as well as THEY hoped". Are you too moronic to even read properly?

In that case you're comparing apples to dingleberries.

Not when you consider how much better every next CDP game did in comparison to the previous one. CDP hoped to make the same jump from The Witcher 3 to Cyberpunk as they did with The Witcher 3 in comparison to The Witcher 2. Meaning they hoped to go from The Witcher 3/Skyrim numbers to GTA 5/Red Dead 2 numbers. They failed to meet this goal.

 

[cvv]

Red Dead 2 numbers...They failed to meet this goal.

RDR2 sold 12 million copies in 3 days. CP sold 13 million in the first two weeks. So not exactly as good....but still pretty fucking good. And a gigantic step up from TW3. Meaning you're about 88% wrong.

 

[RRRrrr]

RDR2 sold 12 million copies in 3 days. CP sold 13 million in the first two weeks. So not exactly as good....but still pretty fucking good. And a gigantic step up from TW3. Meaning you're about 88% wrong.

12 million in 3 days (just on consoles) is a lot better than 13 million in 14 days on all platforms. If CP2077 sold 12 million copies on playstation/xbox, then they'd be comparable. You are the one comparing apples (console sales in 3 days) to oranges (sales across all platforms for 14 days). Meaning you are 99% wrong.

 

[Paul_cz]

Where did I say it was bad you retard. I said "not as well as THEY hoped". Are you too moronic to even read properly?

Your post was dumb, because you said this:

"They expected Red Dead Redemption 2 or GTA 5 level sales, yet failed to achieve even The Witcher 3 levels."

Meanwhile in reality, it sold vastly better than Witcher 3 did for the same period. Expecting a new game to reach same sales on launch as TW3 did over 6 years is...well, retarded. CDP board is not quite that retarded.

And you are comparing apples and oranges. RDR2 shipped (not sold through to customers, but shipped to stores, two different things) 17 million copies in two weeks. Sold-through number is not available.
Cyberpunk sold through - to end customers - 14 million in three weeks - hardly a catastrophe.

 

[RRRrrr]

Your post was dumb, because you said this:

Yep, retard confirmed. Welcome to my ignore list.

 

[Paul_cz]

Yep, retard confirmed. Welcome to my ignore list.

I rest my case. When out of arguments, there's always the echo chamber.

 

[J_C]

Your post was dumb, because you said this:

Yep, retard confirmed. Welcome to my ignore list.

He made a perfectly valid point and you put him on the ignore list? Get the fuck out of the codex you pussy.

 

[RRRrrr]

He made a perfectly valid point and you put him on the ignore list? Get the fuck out of the codex you pussy.

He made a point I addressed specifically in an earlier post on the very same page.