Not at all. I don't know much but I can tell night from day. I hate Bethesda's failures too, just not so much that I let them ruin the substantial fun to be had.
As for writing an official Codex review, I would be completely the wrong person to do Fallout 4 for a lot of reasons. I probably will play it though and I'll be happy to share my impressions. I know, you're holding your breath, right?
Good summary. There's some necessary oversimplification there and a few shots that are just unfounded bitching, but I wouldn't argue with you on most of it.