I plowed through this thread over the last day or so, and there is a reason most of these games are obscure. I played about half of them during the dark times of no real RPGs being released, and they're either terrible or unplayable buggy messes. Prince of Qin is one of the few that I could recommend if you've played all the actual good RPGs already and are looking to kill time. The Fall might be worth plowing through its issues, but it's not some hidden gem underneath. The Infinity Engine and Diablo clones are not worth it even if they're free.
The inner autistic in me still enjoys seeing all these games being tracked down for posterity sake.
Out of curiosity, how many did you play relatively close to completion? I only ask because I've recently had a trend of replaying a bunch of old games, some I thought were shit, some that weren't, and when I actually finished them a good deal ended up turning to be much better or much worse than I thought they were.
Not too many games here that I'd want to commit 20-40 hours into if I'm hating it after the first couple hours. For the games I actually spent some time playing.
I played Prince of Qin and it was a decent Baldur's Gate style game.
The Fall, I was using some unofficial English translation patch so maybe it's better without. It also crashed a lot on me, but might be better on an older Windows version. Bugs and crashing killed any momentum I had with it.
I don't count them as obscure since they had full distribution in big stores in the US, but Silver and Septerra Core were decent JRPG/Western RPG hybrids that I got pretty far into. The Final Fantasy influence is unmistakable.
Other ones that I quit pretty quickly.
Another War, Baldur's Gate style with frustrating combat and a bad English translation that I didn't see getting better.
Gorasul, another BG style game with nothing good to say about it.
Metalheart, I think this was a shitty Fallout Tactics type of game but all I remember is how buggy it was.
Prelude to Darkness might be a hidden classic, but 2 different versions of this just kept on crashing on me so i never made it past the first city.
Any Diablo clone/Hack & Slash mentioned in this thread, my review was that it's generic, bland and probably buggy. I don't know why I played so many of these. Just go replay Diablo, Titan Quest, Sacred or Beyond Divinity instead.
Pillars of Garendall, it came before but I'd describe it as a really RPG lite version of Eschalon.
Devil Whiskey is one that I should probably retry, it was a decent Bard's Tale clone.
There's a bunch of other's that I played but they were so forgettable that I couldn't even tell you anything about them. The only reason I know I played ones like Avadon, Cops 2170, Evil Island, Hexplore, Armor&Amulets, etc is that it says so in my autistic excel spreadsheet of games that I've played.
I'd love to hear more opinions on Teudogar or Omega Syndrome. For the latter, I know the developer just stopped selling it and you can't even pirate a full copy. It had some good buzz on the codex when it came out though.