Putting the 'role' back in role-playing games since 2002.
Donate to Codex
Good Old Games
  • Welcome to rpgcodex.net, a site dedicated to discussing computer based role-playing games in a free and open fashion. We're less strict than other forums, but please refer to the rules.

    "This message is awaiting moderator approval": All new users must pass through our moderation queue before they will be able to post normally. Until your account has "passed" your posts will only be visible to yourself (and moderators) until they are approved. Give us a week to get around to approving / deleting / ignoring your mundane opinion on crap before hassling us about it. Once you have passed the moderation period (think of it as a test), you will be able to post normally, just like all the other retards.

Community RPG Codex Invades Steam

drae

Augur
Joined
Aug 9, 2013
Messages
179
Oh this again won't it be fun

Stop filling the Steam list with shit and we won't have to go through it again.
 

Infinitron

I post news
Patron
Staff Member
Joined
Jan 28, 2011
Messages
99,612
Codex Year of the Donut Serpent in the Staglands Dead State Divinity: Original Sin Project: Eternity Torment: Tides of Numenera Wasteland 2 Shadorwun: Hong Kong Divinity: Original Sin 2 A Beautifully Desolate Campaign Pillars of Eternity 2: Deadfire Pathfinder: Kingmaker Pathfinder: Wrath I'm very into cock and ball torture I helped put crap in Monomyth
It's funny that nobody has realized that the exact same complaints hold true for System Shock 2 (props to anybody consistent enough to demand that SS2 be removed from the list as well - not that we'll do it)
 
Unwanted

jcd

Punished JCD
Patron
Joined
Jan 4, 2012
Messages
10,681
Location
UNATCO HQ
Codex 2014 PC RPG Website of the Year, 2015 Codex 2016 - The Age of Grimoire Bubbles In Memoria
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
 
Last edited:

felipepepe

Codex's Heretic
Patron
Joined
Feb 2, 2007
Messages
17,310
Location
Terra da Garoa
the Codex wasn’t formed to celebrate or promote the redeeming factors of Diablo and Dark Souls. It is not our creed or our mission, and whilst we may enjoy those games we don’t place it in our list of official games RPGCodex recommends
So sayeth the sole founder and hivemind ruler of the Codex?
 

drae

Augur
Joined
Aug 9, 2013
Messages
179
It's funny that nobody has realized that the exact same complaints hold true for System Shock 2 (props to anybody consistent enough to demand that SS2 be removed from the list as well - not that we'll do it)

As long as you provide consistency one way or the other. Which means I expect to see Borderlands on your list any moment now.

So sayeth the sole founder and hivemind ruler of the Codex?

That's what the Codex was formed for. Unless it's changed in the decade I've been visiting the site.
 

V_K

Arcane
Joined
Nov 3, 2013
Messages
7,714
Location
at a Nowhere near you
It's funny that nobody has realized that the exact same complaints hold true for System Shock 2 (props to anybody consistent enough to demand that SS2 be removed from the list as well - not that we'll do it)
It's possible to finish SS2 without good reflexes if you build your character right - I did and I'm dyspraxic. That's not true for DS from what I've heard.
(I don't object to its presence on Codex list though. Just making a point for the sake of making a point)
 

felipepepe

Codex's Heretic
Patron
Joined
Feb 2, 2007
Messages
17,310
Location
Terra da Garoa
That's what the Codex was formed for. Unless it's changed in the decade I've been visiting the site.
Yes, I fully remember the founding fathers signing a letter about what's an RPG and what's not, deciding what kind of game should be recommended and what not. :roll:

I mean, let's check the first articles posted here. Oh, what's this, Divine Divinity and Grandia II? Filthy Action-RPGs and JRPG in muh 2002 Codex? Also, a debate on whatever Freelancer is or isn't an RPG?

All in all, there is little doubt in my mind that Freelancer is, indeed an RPG.
Oh, the glory and purity of the 2002's! :salute:
 

drae

Augur
Joined
Aug 9, 2013
Messages
179
Like I said, if you want to put good action-RPGs on Steam then be consistent. Chuck them all in there. That includes Borderlands. If you don't you're just promoting games the people in the little mod circle like.

So add Borderlands to the list, or shut the fuck up Felipe.
 

felipepepe

Codex's Heretic
Patron
Joined
Feb 2, 2007
Messages
17,310
Location
Terra da Garoa
Proven to be full of shit, you're moving goalposts, eh?

Dark Souls is in because it was voted #14 best RPG on our list. System Shock 2 was #22. Borderlands ranked at #164. That's the result of 234 people voting, not a little mod circle. As opposed to one butthurt guy fabricating "the mission of the Codex".
 

Infinitron

I post news
Patron
Staff Member
Joined
Jan 28, 2011
Messages
99,612
Codex Year of the Donut Serpent in the Staglands Dead State Divinity: Original Sin Project: Eternity Torment: Tides of Numenera Wasteland 2 Shadorwun: Hong Kong Divinity: Original Sin 2 A Beautifully Desolate Campaign Pillars of Eternity 2: Deadfire Pathfinder: Kingmaker Pathfinder: Wrath I'm very into cock and ball torture I helped put crap in Monomyth
Proven to be full of shit, you're moving goalposts, eh?

Dark Souls is in the list because it was voted #14 best RPG on our list. System Shock 2 was #22. That's the result of 234 people voting, not a little mod circle. As opposed to one butthurt guy in the forums fabricating "the mission of the Codex".

I'd like to say that the reason Dark Souls was added was because it's a hardcore fucking dungeon crawler with best-of-class action-RPG mechanics, but its enduring popularity on the Codex (hundreds of pages-long threads, and not full of shitposting like Bioware threads) certainly helped cement that reputation.
 

Zeriel

Arcane
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
13,963
I'm fine with Dark Souls being recommended by the curator page. It was in the Codex recommends list and is ultimately a good game.

But not a good RPG, which is why it shouldn't be on the list. But the Codex has changed and this is a part of its new direction etc etc.

If DS2 gets on there the descent into absurdity will be complete.

it already is on there
 
Joined
Apr 4, 2007
Messages
3,585
Location
Motherfuckerville
It's possible to finish SS2 without good reflexes if you build your character right - I did and I'm dyspraxic. That's not true for DS from what I've heard.

Greatshield builds that stack lots of poise in Dark Souls 1 can obviate most any challenge the game holds while requiring little in the way of reflex-based prowess. Spell-casting builds can avoid a lot of the tense positioning and timing game that melee characters have to engage with. While reflexes are important, character building and proper item/inventory (ab)use can carry a weak player.


As others have said, if games like System Shock 2, Vampire: Bloodlines, Morrowind, Gothic, Alpha Protocol, Deus Ex are all on the list, then there's few valid reasons to exclude Dark Souls. Every single one of those games follows the same styyle of design what with character build determining the available abilities and the player's reflexive and tactical skills determining the effectiveness of their use.
 

dnf

Pedophile
Dumbfuck Shitposter
Joined
Nov 4, 2011
Messages
5,885
so are you keeping dark souls ?

PS. im going through TC remommendations and surprise surprise they only have strategy games there. Who would have thought
And what kind of strategy games are we talking about here? Turn based, real time, grand, minor,4x,laptop guy without stats,...?
 

Jasede

Arcane
Patron
Joined
Jan 4, 2005
Messages
24,793
Insert Title Here RPG Wokedex Codex Year of the Donut I'm very into cock and ball torture
Part of the reason I joined the RPG Codex is to find decent RPG. Where the heck are the sort of games I used to play.

Sorry for quoting from another thread but this ! People join Codex to find decent RPGs and we recommend fucking Dark Souls !! Is this where we have come to ?
You don't add games that are what the Codex used to stand for because they are in early access (and rightfully so) and you add that clusterfuck of anime and rolling around the bad guy until he commits seppuku.
This nigga thinks there's anime in Dark Souls!
Stone him!


Guyze plz remove Wizardry 8 from that list if it's on it, too similar to that weeaboo Wizardry 1-5 shit
 

Cowboy Moment

Arcane
Joined
Feb 8, 2011
Messages
4,407
Like I said before in the Top70 thread, I think Dark Souls is as much of an RPG as Castlevania: Symphony of the Night, which in my opinion is not very much. Still, it's close enough, and a truly excellent game, so there's no shame in having it on the list. Same as there was no shame in having Codex review the likes of Pathologic or Mark of the Ninja, which generated some butthurt from the "but but but it's not an rpg!" crowd as well.

That said, you could remove it and I wouldn't care. As we observed earlier, the only thing it does is promote the Codex curator as both DS games are very popular, and now we show up on their store pages. Whether that's a good or bad thing is unclear to me at the moment.
 

Grunker

RPG Codex Ghost
Patron
Joined
Oct 19, 2009
Messages
27,761
Location
Copenhagen
Like I said before in the Top70 thread, I think Dark Souls is as much of an RPG as Castlevania: Symphony of the Night, which in my opinion is not very much. Still, it's close enough, and a truly excellent game, so there's no shame in having it on the list. Same as there was no shame in having Codex review the likes of Pathologic or Mark of the Ninja, which generated some butthurt from the "but but but it's not an rpg!" crowd as well.

That said, you could remove it and I wouldn't care. As we observed earlier, the only thing it does is promote the Codex curator as both DS games are very popular, and now we show up on their store pages. Whether that's a good or bad thing is unclear to me at the moment.

This is, word for word, my opinion as well.
 

Zeriel

Arcane
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
13,963
Like I said before in the Top70 thread, I think Dark Souls is as much of an RPG as Castlevania: Symphony of the Night, which in my opinion is not very much. Still, it's close enough, and a truly excellent game, so there's no shame in having it on the list. Same as there was no shame in having Codex review the likes of Pathologic or Mark of the Ninja, which generated some butthurt from the "but but but it's not an rpg!" crowd as well.

That said, you could remove it and I wouldn't care. As we observed earlier, the only thing it does is promote the Codex curator as both DS games are very popular, and now we show up on their store pages. Whether that's a good or bad thing is unclear to me at the moment.

This is, word for word, my opinion as well.

Ditto. Whether or not promoting the Codex curator list is desirable is really the only question here.
 

Cowboy Moment

Arcane
Joined
Feb 8, 2011
Messages
4,407
Like I said before in the Top70 thread, I think Dark Souls is as much of an RPG as Castlevania: Symphony of the Night, which in my opinion is not very much. Still, it's close enough, and a truly excellent game, so there's no shame in having it on the list. Same as there was no shame in having Codex review the likes of Pathologic or Mark of the Ninja, which generated some butthurt from the "but but but it's not an rpg!" crowd as well.

That said, you could remove it and I wouldn't care. As we observed earlier, the only thing it does is promote the Codex curator as both DS games are very popular, and now we show up on their store pages. Whether that's a good or bad thing is unclear to me at the moment.

This is, word for word, my opinion as well.

Ditto. Whether or not promoting the Codex curator list is desirable is really the only question here.

I feel like some people believe that the recommended games list should be a kind of ideological statement, a manifesto of the most desirable qualities in an RPG. The problem with that is that there is no such thing, there's (obviously) not even consensus on what an RPG is, much less a good one. Closest thing is the Top70, and you do have Dark Souls there, for better or worse. However, even if we did have the consensus, putting a manifesto like that on Steam serves little purpose. If you're a Codex regular, you are very likely to already have at least heard of all the games we're recommending - I certainly have.

The ultimate purpose of the curator is to actively encourage incline by giving a bit more visibility to good games that need it. In that sense, it's a good idea to put the likes of Neo Scavenger there, even though it appears on no top lists and no vote was held regarding its inclusion. And when I say "good games", I mean ones that agree with the most basic Codexian values - values which transcend the RPG genre - games which are well designed, complex, revel in being games rather than interactive movies, engage the player and demand attention rather than ferrying them across a linear corridor while they press A for Awesome, have real depth and reward thinking on one's own rather than following a quest compass. I find that whether I go into the Strategy section, the Adventure forum, or GRPGD, this is what people like and focus on.

And if that's the criteria, Dark Souls fits very well, and it's probably not a bad idea to have people who like Dark Souls check out our list. Should be fine so long as we don't start recommending Boredomlands just because it's popular.
 

Grunker

RPG Codex Ghost
Patron
Joined
Oct 19, 2009
Messages
27,761
Location
Copenhagen
Like I said before in the Top70 thread, I think Dark Souls is as much of an RPG as Castlevania: Symphony of the Night, which in my opinion is not very much. Still, it's close enough, and a truly excellent game, so there's no shame in having it on the list. Same as there was no shame in having Codex review the likes of Pathologic or Mark of the Ninja, which generated some butthurt from the "but but but it's not an rpg!" crowd as well.

That said, you could remove it and I wouldn't care. As we observed earlier, the only thing it does is promote the Codex curator as both DS games are very popular, and now we show up on their store pages. Whether that's a good or bad thing is unclear to me at the moment.

This is, word for word, my opinion as well.

Ditto. Whether or not promoting the Codex curator list is desirable is really the only question here.

I feel like some people believe that the recommended games list should be a kind of ideological statement, a manifesto of the most desirable qualities in an RPG. The problem with that is that there is no such thing, there's (obviously) not even consensus on what an RPG is, much less a good one. Closest thing is the Top70, and you do have Dark Souls there, for better or worse. However, even if we did have the consensus, putting a manifesto like that on Steam serves little purpose. If you're a Codex regular, you are very likely to already have at least heard of all the games we're recommending - I certainly have.

The ultimate purpose of the curator is to actively encourage incline by giving a bit more visibility to good games that need it. In that sense, it's a good idea to put the likes of Neo Scavenger there, even though it appears on no top lists and no vote was held regarding its inclusion. And when I say "good games", I mean ones that agree with the most basic Codexian values - values which transcend the RPG genre - games which are well designed, complex, revel in being games rather than interactive movies, engage the player and demand attention rather than ferrying them across a linear corridor while they press A for Awesome, have real depth and reward thinking on one's own rather than following a quest compass. I find that whether I go into the Strategy section, the Adventure forum, or GRPGD, this is what people like and focus on.

And if that's the criteria, Dark Souls fits very well, and it's probably not a bad idea to have people who like Dark Souls check out our list. Should be fine so long as we don't start recommending Boredomlands just because it's popular.

I agree with most of this, but many users are of the opinion that "The Codex shouldn't compromise."

I am of the belief that a popular Curator promoting games that actually have merit versus all the other curators which pretty much just slam popular games on there has a lot of merit, and I think it is a worthy pursuit. And we're actually one of the more popular curators atm.
 

Drakron

Arcane
Joined
May 19, 2005
Messages
6,326
We might as well put CoD and AC on the list ... I am pretty sure the things that qualify as being a RPG end up open to debate, heck like Mass Effect.

I still dont get why the Amazon Princess is not on the list, its a RPG with at least a mutually exclusive path, you even get a option of what gender and what class you play as ... it have more of a RPG that dark Souls.
 

As an Amazon Associate, rpgcodex.net earns from qualifying purchases.
Back
Top Bottom