Sword has one of the better uniques, Red Dragon, but it has a 6 INT requirement as well as 6 DEX for the sword feats, 6 AGI if you want to pair it with the Phantom Dancer armor, and 7 STR to take Decapitate.
unique that you obtain after expedition is over or in deep caverns might as well not exist
You can rush through Expedition really fast, especially with the above build since you have stealth.
But after the CP nerf Red Dragon is def. worse than top crafted machetes, it was very close before already.
No? 160q curved tungsten machete is 24-58 damage, 180% crit damage. Red dragon is 30-40 damage, 300% crit damage. So 490% vs. 850% crit damage with Cheap shots and specced CP. A lil' bit less in practice, because I'd get points in flurry spec. Crafted only have crit chance going for them - 7% more on a curved tungsten with weaponsmith. It's closer now, but before the nerf weebsword was the undisputed king with its 1,1k crit damage.
That's prettly low for a crit, you don't take Ripper?
With machete you'd spec Onslaught and q160 isn't top quality.
I didn't include Ripper here because it depends on the enemy health and is not displayed in combat stats, hard to calculate. Even with Ripper, a weapon with higher crit damage will benefit more from it.
Onslaught spec is worse than CP spec on either weapon. It provides less damage per point, can disappear after a miss and kinda has a windup time, you need to build it up, whereas high crit damage is there from the start.
~160 quality is p. much the best you can realistically expect to get. Max 164 from Constantine or 169 from Hannah. Good luck getting tungsten plates out of Constantine, it's all RNG. There's also the new waterways dungeon, which might have something of higher quality, but I went through it like 6? 7? times and haven't seen tungsten of that high quality there. Dunno if saves-cumming works on container loot. And I don't even consider the components from DC.