Borelli
Arcane
- Joined
- Dec 5, 2012
- Messages
- 1,310
Just finished Game of Thrones RPG by Cyanide. Here are my thoughts on it:
The combat is real time withpause slowdown, not bad in concept but for most of the game it is too easy to engage you. The first time combat felt like fun was near the ending chapters when they throw some tougher encounters at you. In fact it reminds me of Dragon Age the most. When it comes to filler combat, most of the combat has story reasons for it but at certain parts the game wants to be a dungeon crawler and here it feels weird for you to scour the whole castle killing everything in sight, this would not be weird in other games but since i recently watched the GoT show i hold this to a more "realistic" standard. However even with this the total time spent in combat is much lesser than the other RPGs. Bottom line, boring but not so much that you want to stop playing the game.
Game's main problem is that the RPG elements are so useless, the skills and attributes are of +% variety which is just plain dull, ability selection is decent decent though, with lots of status effects and possible skill combos. The devs have managed to accomplish a lot given that all characters are just warriors. Secondly, there are coins at random barrels. Why? I can tolerate this shit in a JRPG made for schoolkids with too much free time who like to enter people houses and click on every pixel but in a "serious" game this totally messed up the mood. I don't remember people in the show stopping during dialogue to loot random barrels. Ok, i am overreacting, this doesn't really change the game but the total money you get from clicking around is like less than 5% (and this is a game where money is mostly useless). Some of the loot is slightly hidden which may seem like the game rewards exploration, but it really doesn't, the levels are mostly linear and having a LOOT BE HERE button popup when you walk near pickable objects isn't really exploration.
Graphically, the characters look good while the scenery is average, art style is very realistic with very little oversized armors and the like (although it has them a little, especially on the principal characters), what i didn't like is how many people are sporting full plates, fighting redshirts who are lightly armored is ok since the show has implied that heroes can easily beat several ordinary people, however with everybody wearing full plates muh immersion is being ruined, although i do not know if the game is based on the book or the show (the intro music led me to believe it was the show hence my nitpicking with the armors). Also, why so many people wear hoods?
The game is divided into small chapters which is good for the pacing but it makes the individual parts very linear, oh well you can't have it all. Side quests are few but very well made and fit the tone. The voice acting is ok, not bad but nothing extraordinary.
The story is ... really really good. Low key, no saving the world stuff, very little fantasy elements, gritty and mature (of course, since this is GoT we are talking about), following two separate character's intersecting storylines which ends up really interesting. The endings are depressing no matter how you choose it.
If i was a serious game reviewer i would have given it 3 trolls, but i am not so i leave it at 4. I liked the story that much.
The combat is real time with
Game's main problem is that the RPG elements are so useless, the skills and attributes are of +% variety which is just plain dull, ability selection is decent decent though, with lots of status effects and possible skill combos. The devs have managed to accomplish a lot given that all characters are just warriors. Secondly, there are coins at random barrels. Why? I can tolerate this shit in a JRPG made for schoolkids with too much free time who like to enter people houses and click on every pixel but in a "serious" game this totally messed up the mood. I don't remember people in the show stopping during dialogue to loot random barrels. Ok, i am overreacting, this doesn't really change the game but the total money you get from clicking around is like less than 5% (and this is a game where money is mostly useless). Some of the loot is slightly hidden which may seem like the game rewards exploration, but it really doesn't, the levels are mostly linear and having a LOOT BE HERE button popup when you walk near pickable objects isn't really exploration.
Graphically, the characters look good while the scenery is average, art style is very realistic with very little oversized armors and the like (although it has them a little, especially on the principal characters), what i didn't like is how many people are sporting full plates, fighting redshirts who are lightly armored is ok since the show has implied that heroes can easily beat several ordinary people, however with everybody wearing full plates muh immersion is being ruined, although i do not know if the game is based on the book or the show (the intro music led me to believe it was the show hence my nitpicking with the armors). Also, why so many people wear hoods?
The game is divided into small chapters which is good for the pacing but it makes the individual parts very linear, oh well you can't have it all. Side quests are few but very well made and fit the tone. The voice acting is ok, not bad but nothing extraordinary.
The story is ... really really good. Low key, no saving the world stuff, very little fantasy elements, gritty and mature (of course, since this is GoT we are talking about), following two separate character's intersecting storylines which ends up really interesting. The endings are depressing no matter how you choose it.
If i was a serious game reviewer i would have given it 3 trolls, but i am not so i leave it at 4. I liked the story that much.