Ok, I finally finished Siege of Dragonspear for the first time (during my current BG saga playthrough).
It's much better than I thought (yet my expectations were incredibly low):
- some encounters are fine and well taught
- locations look really good! (I thought it would be blurry shit known from BGEE companion quests)
- there are parts of writing not especially bad and the story - even if naive and "another high-fantasy bullshit" - goes smoothly
- voice acting and length - you don't feel like playing another fan mod
- new companions are mostly good! (much better than Neera/Dorn/Rajiiisssh - shaman class is fun to play, scald with some itemization can be very potent, archer tearing enemies in no time, the gnome is an ok cleric/thief)
- battle of dragonspear is exhausting (in a good way
) - I used almost all my spells and a lot of potions, and a few combats were rather hard
But still, it's Beamdog so a lot of bullshit there:
- whole SoD is linear as fuck
- evil choices are creepy and cringe
- eh... Neera and Rajish are still there (Neera being annoying as a character is at least a competent spellcaster, but paki just sucks balls and is useless!) :/
- there is literally no new enemy - we are fighting dragons, vampires, liches, ilithids, and demons, and even the final boss is taken from another game!
- story... fuck, that plot is thin as paper and just stupid; crusade to conquer half of Sword Coast to open a portal to hell to rise dead people from the dead... WTF? WHOS IDEA IS THIS? all Infinite games had better plots! and Celar is an insanely bad-written character.
- SJW stuff - it's not just Mizogina, there is more, but more subtle (stronk wymyn etc)
- that's a long game to explain why you end with Minsc, Dynaheir, Jaheira, Kahlid and Imonen in BG2... I mean they could just add a cutscene with one person dying, a trial and a whole Epilogue and we would be set
- oh, trial - I know a lot of people love trials in games like Chrono Trigger or NWN2 but here and there are little-to-no consequences of those trials, and SoD is no different.
- after the prologue, your exp is set to 250k just like this... I don't like such gimmicks...
- companions switching - arghhh! You can't do some companions quests without them in your party, so for max gains, you should shuffle your team, which is just stupid and tedious, as you should usually switch items between party members which gets boring really fast...
Overall if you are an Infinity Engine hard fan you will have a lot of fun with that - more exploring, a lot of great encounters, and nice maps.
If you just play BG saga from time to time just for that "adventure feeling" - feel free to skip this, you will lose nothing and save some time.
If you hate BG then SoD won't change your mind :D .
For me - 4/10, and would not replay again (really, probably I would just cheat exp and items to BG2 to save some time).