I always thought PoE was an incline game, but for some reason, I got the impression that it isn't very good just through passively reading posts across the Codex. Can anyone verify?
If you're a new player I wouldn't concern myself with anything you read on the forums right now. While by no means perfect, the game has a lot to offer a new player and the community has developed tools to ease you into it. If you're playing OSRS, it should be a breeze. Many of the criticisms apply to veteran players only, especially veterans who were into the gigazoom. Speaking of which, the top end of the zooming has been significantly reigned it. While it's still possible to clear very fast, you no longer have the ability to clear 25% of the map on touching a monster, like you once used to.
Fuck, just look at Grunker for example. He wants to stick to Righteous Fire. And he's not alone in this regard. Many people nowadays will trade clear speed for comfy and Righteous Fire is very difficult to beat in that area.
In another instance of this: I know a girl who got her boyfriend into PoE recently. This league they played for real for the first time. He ran Righteous Fire and she ran Summon Raging Spirits. Both builds that aren't known for their clear speed. They made a lot of bank, had tons of fun and had a bunch of "firsts".