Regular Str Cleric that will have same casting ability score as your Crusader using a Two handed and power attack does not do less damage. Especially when you go into Enlarging that increases weapon damage by a lot.
And even with all the buffs, all these clerics are weaker in pure combat ability than a well build Barbarian or pure Fighter. In my campaign Amiri did a lot more damage then Harrim when both were buffed about the same. And Nok Nok did more damage than both to those he could sneak attack.
3.5e Cleric could outdamage fighter classes in melee, pathfinder ones no longer can unless you compare a buffed cleric to unbuffed fighter. But in a good party that shares buffs with those that can best use it, Fighters, Barbarians and Rogues will always outdamage Crusaders and Clerics. What clerics have is lots of spells that can help in encounters and Crusaders lose a significant number of those.
Your point is that you made a Crusader that is not useless. Good for you, it is still subpar to other choices. That will not change no matter how much you try to convince us. You are just that PnP player that came up with something he considers fun and wants to play it no matter. Just stop trying to show it as something it is not.
I don’t play pnp, I’ve just been playing rpgs since gold box and enjoy builds built around buffing and debuffing, then every character being competent (or preferably better) at doing damage with the blade and arrow to minimize rests.
I’m not going to accept claims of subpar in a vacuum. There is no other weapon in the game that gives you 18x (6 range with 3 multiplier) worth of crit at lvl 12ish like Lion’s Claw. You should know as well as anyone the ridiculous number of sources of extra damage (per attack) there are floating around this game. Put those two things together and I either have the better of the argument or we’re both doing (more than) sufficient damage either way, except I get to heal the rest of the party and keep up Archon’s and Death Wards or whatever where fighter doesn’t or I stay alive a lot easier than a regular cleric running around with a two-hander.
I’m the one who puts one on Tristan so I know that all too well. And power attack without shatter on a regular cleric? Your theory has some holes in it.
I won’t say anymore because I’ve only tested the build at the beginning (starts out with two attacks, and you can take double slice too if you want) and the end, but it does well at both.