gurugeorge
Arcane
Complete nonsense, I repeat a Good action is not a non-Lawful one by default which is how the game treats itI don't think choice being on a single axis is a problem in itself, the paladin dilemma of having to choose between benevolence and law is pretty old.
You’re both right. The “Paladin dilemma” is a false dichotomy but it’s so pervasive now in the culture most aren’t even aware of it (especially these writers). The Pozzed have made a fetish of it.
It was common enough throughout history (usually known as “cheap grace” among other names) but at least within Christianity there’s a framework to correct it. The Poz ditching of Xianity took the brakes off the train so everything collapses into a banal CG/LE axis resulting in things like ACAB.
In practice it plays out as glibertarianism run amok which is why all the corps are so shit hot on it. Lets them get away with literal murder as long as they LARP as CG with the rainbow flag nonsense.
Yeah I think this is true.
But! They've also written Regill, who's universally recognized as pretty much the best-written (perhaps best-acted too) character in the game.
It's a "return of the repressed" type of thing - they have to piss and moan about following rules, but they can't help but be secretly attracted to it.
I think I said this before somewhere, but the popularity of Regill mirrors the popularity of Rorschach in Watchmen, who CG(CN?) Alan Moore wrote as a pisstake of Ayn Rand's Mr A. But in doing so he put more soul and realism into the character than any of the others