Well, there is a moment when he says 'You've been trying to wipe them out for weeks. He did it [wipe out the LA sabbat] in a night!'. So that's not the problem. The Sheriff just never had the opportunity you had. Or he was simply canonically too weak to do a frontal assault on Hallowbrook
That makes sense, but then again you never see Sheriff in combat against actual Sabbat, minus that one small cutscene in the tutorial. Makes you wonder about his power level. Is he on Andrei's level or not?
Abbrams, Therese, Nines are all younger than him and competent at what they are trying to do.
Eh, Abrams couldn't get rid of that gargoyle. Nines feels like someones Sonic OC in terms of "look how badass and noble he is, he has no bad qualities!", barely feels like an actual character, and Therese is actually older than LaCroix if we're going by 5e rules, she's the childe of a Malkavian methuselah or something.