Feel free to boo at me for this one.
I just remembered that I bought Minecraft earlier this year but never even installed it, let alone played it. I know, late to the party and all that.
So I install, play the game, muck around a bit, see all the similarities to Terraria, then remember I have to build a shelter very soon or some damn monsters are gonna get me. I spotted a small island off the coast, so I head over there and make it my "base" and hope for the best. Then I decide to start crafting something.
After 5 minutes I realize that either I'm doing something wrong or I'm missing something, as the most useful thing I've managed to craft is a stick. There is no in-game database/journal to keep track of the recipes, and there's no "Guide" NPC to help me keep track. After mucking around a bit, surviving the night (monsters don't seem to like islands) I try again...and get absolutely nowhere.
Admitting to myself that I must be stupid, I Alt-Tab to a browser and look up "Minecraft Beginner's Guide". That only tells me
what I should be doing and what resources to look for, but now
how to craft things. So I dig deeper until I discover 2 things:
# Some recipes require that the items be placed in the proper squares in the crafting window.
# Everyone suggests just looking up the recipes online, as there's no way to discover them in-game except by trial and error.
...
I don't mind the first point at all, except that the game doesn't see a reason to inform me of this fact. But the second?
X 100.
I've criticized Terraria's crafting system for being redundant, but that's Mensa-level quality stuff compared to this. This is early 1980's-era level of game design, the kind that any sensible developer abandoned decades ago, for good reason.
The best part about Terraria is discovering things on your own once you've been pointed in the right direction. Minecraft probably sports thousands of recipes, yet deliberately acts this obtuse about them? Not even giving you a "sample" crafting recipe to get people going?
I'm sorry, I don't have time for this. The aspies can have this game, Terraria is good enough for me.
EDIT: Clarity.